3 min read

I am writing to comment on Gary Fogg’s May 23 guest column post, “The bear hunting debate,” about the referendum to ban the use of bear baiting, hounding, and trapping.

First, I take issue with Mr. Fogg’s statement that the referendum is a reflection of “…the impact of big money in American politics… with the Humane Society of the United States… grinding away at our institutions and what is left of Maine’s rural way of life.”

The referendum is the reflection of the voices of more than 78,000 Maine voters who signed petitions asking that recreational bear hunters stop using traps, bait, and hounds. Those 78,000 signatures from our friends and neighbors are what bring the question to the ballot box for all Mainers to vote on in November.

Second, Mr. Fogg does not seem to be aware that the Humane Society of the United States works for animals in many, many capacities, with anti-cruelty legislation being just one part. A quick visit to the HSUS website shows the scope of their work. I am personally aware of the HSUS assisting local Maine shelters in animal rescue, abuse, and hoarding situations. The HSUS also provides ongoing advice and assistance in best practices sheltering.

Third, I would ask that Mr. Fogg look to his own side of this debate to see where the money is coming from to defeat this citizen initiative.

Advertisement

Fourth, Mr. Fogg is correct that bear hunting is a tradition in Maine. However, cruelty is not. Mainers should know that we are the only state in the entire country that allows recreational trapping of bears. There is no recreational bear trapping in Colorado, Wyoming, Utah, or any other state. Only in Maine. And that is a black mark on our hunting and wildlife heritage.

I am not going to address Mr. Fogg’s comments on the management of our bear population. Others, with more wildlife science and biology than I have, will continue to present facts and statistics showing that trapping, hounding and baiting are unnecessary practices.

I would like to finish on a personal note as a dog owner and a board member of the Coastal Humane Society in Brunswick.

Animal welfare is extremely important to me. I am horrified by the practice of bear hounding. Packs of dogs are outfitted with radio collars and set off on a scent, usually from a bait pile. The chase can be a long one. When the bear finally tires, one of two things will happen. The bear may climb a tree, from which it is shot by the hunter, who has followed the radio signals. Or, the bear may turn and fight, in which case both species are often mauled, sometimes resulting in severe wounds, or even death, to the dogs.

Until this referendum, I was unaware of the cruelty going on in our woods. One way I educated myself was finding and watching online videos of bear trapping, bear hounding and bear baiting. Some of these I found very difficult to view. Seeing a bear struggling to free itself from a cable snare trap — hearing a single, off- camera gunshot and watching a bear fall to the ground — scenes such as these were gut wrenching for me.

There will be many articles, interviews, TV spots, and online posts about this referendum over the summer and into the fall. Asking for myself, and for more humane treatment of Maine’s beloved black bears, please make up your own mind. Get your facts from a variety of sources and make your own informed opinion — and a wellinformed vote on November 4.

———

Constance McCabe is a resident of Harpswell, has owned McCabe + Duval in Portland for 26 years and is a board member at Coastal Humane Society.



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.