3 min read

Many of us carry our lives around in a six-inch piece of glass and metal these days. Obviously, such a thing was never envisioned by the Founders.

So through a little loophole in the law, a number of people have been prosecuted and convicted because various police agencies didn’t think they needed to ask permission before snooping through a smartphone or a cell phone at the time of an arrest.

That changed Wednesday, though, with a sweeping ruling by the Supreme Court, which said in part, “ The police generally may not, without a warrant, search digital information on a cell phone seized from an individual who has been arrested.” Writing for the court, Chief Justice John Roberts said that warr antless searches are only acceptable in specific exigent circumstances such as if a bomb was expected to detonate. Justice Alito wrote a separate but concurring opinion.

It was unusual in these polarized times, in that it was a unanimous verdict. This Court has issued 46 unanimous opinions, or two- thirds of the opinions released this term, which is very unusual for the Supreme Court.

And it was also unusual in that the verdict was such an important win for privacy issues.

Advertisement

Now, if someone is arrested, and police say there is reason to suspect that evidence is on a mobile phone, they must do what they have to do in cases where evidence may be in one’s home on written paper.

Get a warrant.

The phone can be impounded, so the owner can’t delete material, but until a judge signs the order, police can’t look through a mobile phone, or use anything that may be on a mobile phone, to prefer new charges, or obtain other warrants for other locations.

It’s a victory for the civil liberties of all Americans, whether they are ever arrested or not. This decision will be examined when other, related issues arise.

For instance, whether a corporation can review your browsing history to send you advertising texts that you have to pay for.

Or whether your employer can scan your call records or read your saved texts, and use that information against you.

Advertisement

Our mobile phones are increasingly an extension of our very selves. They’re far more than just a list of telephone numbers we call regularly. We keep credit card and banking data, our health records, our updated resumes, our children’s photographs, our innermost thoughts, our favorite music, our political arguments, all within a tiny device that we keep closer to us than we keep most family members.

The High Court has recognized that reality, whether it’s a healthy reality or not. And bravo. They’ve upheld the spirit of the 4th Amendment, keeping us free from unreasonable searches and seizures in our new viritual persons and our digital papers.

Jurisprudence works best when it works together. The mobile privacy case will be a strong one going forward, because it had the support of all the justices.



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.