3 min read

Ever since Donald Trump walked away with the presidency half of the nation has tried to make sense of how that could have possibly come about. More accurately, they refuse to make sense of it because then they’d have to finally accept that totally surreal defeat. Politics as previously practiced was stood on its head by the escalator descending audacity of a wholly uncredentialed interloper openly boasting that: “I could stand in the middle of Fifth Avenue and shoot somebody and I wouldn’t lose voters.”  

If any of the other Republican candidates had won an electoral triumph over Hillary Clinton’s slim 2.1% advantage in the popular vote no mainstream Democratic accusations of illegitimacy would have been made. Despite all “Resistance” protest, Trump’s self-surprising victory was a constitutionally correct outcome no matter how unanticipated or insufferable. This time around there weren’t even any hanging chads or need for Supreme Court intervention. Russian interference would have occurred anyway and Bill Clinton was twice elected without getting 50% of the national vote. Like it or not, America’s choice of Donald J. Trump as chief executive was an altogether precedented and legally done deal. It’s what democracy looks like, warts and all, as originally designed and long accepted as a pretty good functional delivery system for freedom many other nations have envied and emulated.  

Despite that reality, for Democrats, hell hath no fury like Hillary being scorned by a victorious one-man perfect storm of all they find reprehensible. Three years later that fury hasn’t abated. Anti-Trump punditry continually opines on the inconceivability of anyone politically aligning themselves with such a buffoonish president’s 24-7 embarrassment of his office, or a party willing to tolerate such blatant nonstop governmental improprieties. That argument is gospel to the one-note Democratic choir but remains unpersuasive in getting those on the right to join the chorus.  

Democrats today are seemingly incapable of envisioning themselves walking in the opposition’s shoes. They truly just don’t get how anyone can think differently from themselves. Close-mindedness doesn’t apply to them but is a chronic condition of those on the opposite side of the aisle. Political correctness is theirs alone. Their side’s infighting aside, their politics is the way, the truth, and the light. Republicans would understand that if they’d just abandon their blind partisan allegiance at any cost. Any reasonable person must see how Trump is the personification of wrong. No right-minded Republican will vote for him a second time, only the most fervent Tea Party loyalist. Given Trump’s endless excesses, 2020’s Democratic candidate will certainly prevail due to a finally exasperated Republican crossover vote.  

That heartening scenario has now suddenly given way to a far less confident political roll of the dice. The Democrats’ renewed pursuit of an impeachment wild card indicates that they’re not confident of that crossover certainty.  

Unfortunately, partisan ideology, left or right, can’t so easily change its spots. The unasked question which no one on my journalistic radar has pursued is: “How reprehensible would a sitting Democratic president have to be for Democrats to vote Republican?”  

Advertisement

Bill Clinton’s #MeToo moment in the Oval Office didn’t meet that bar. Kenneth Starr’s Whitewater inquiry was dismissed as a Republican witch-hunt. Ed Snowden’s whistle-blowing on Obama was similarly ignored. None are held by Democrats as even remotely analogous to Donald Trump’s mega egregious personal failings or legal controversies.  

Whatever one’s acceptance of actuality, just suppose a Democratic president equaled or surpassed Trump’s litany of misconduct. Would Dems join Republicans in calling for impeachment or defensively rationalize continued support in the belief that doing so would maintain crucial control of the executive branch?  

Democrats have spent nearly three years of Trump’s presidency obsessed with ousting him from office rather than making a compelling case for why they should hold it. Republicans have spent that time dismantling big government and reducing taxes while expanding corporate sovereignty. Whether Trump survives his first term or manages a second one, Republicans will remain a major electoral entity at fundamental odds with Democratic values. They walk and talk about their political correctness, their belief system. Democrats need to acknowledge that and get behind a progressive candidate that addresses what the majority of Americans hold as common inequities, fears and aspirations. Someone that speaks to long-term unity rather than continued high-fived short-term home-team dominance fixated more and more on winning with less and less concern of what fundamentally remains the goal.  

Gary Anderson lives in Bath. 

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.