3 min read

To allow more sunlight in thawing winter road surfaces.  

To remove trees that could be a fatal obstruction if hit by a vehicle.  

To minimize animal habitat immediate to the roadway.  

To reduce the possibility of large limbs or entire trees falling onto traffic.  

That’s the official explanation behind the devastating destruction of what were always beautiful and often majestic forested sections along the Route 1 corridor between Brunswick and Bath. Safety. Protecting motorists that might otherwise be injured. Just another downside of our frequently pesky man vs. nature interface. I suspected that was the case, but called the MDOT just to confirm that this was a sanctioned intent of responsible government stewardship and not a wantonly brutal inexplicable disfigurement of the landscape such as all appearances would indicate.  

The spokesperson to whom I was directed was altogether disarming and convincingly transparent as to the what and why of the anticipated controversy. He likened it to the shock of “suddenly going from a ponytail to a shaved head.” Wanting to be listened to rather than summarily dismissed, I tried as hard as I could not to sound combative in criticizing what seemed an unnecessarily extreme solution to problems I comprehend as serious possibilities but not sufficiently warranting such a traumatically heavy-handed remedy.  

Advertisement

Maybe the environmental “haircut” needn’t be so draconian in its obvious economy of maintenance frequency. Maybe more consideration could have been given to the now damage-control-acknowledged aesthetic and environmental concerns. Couldn’t the public have been provided a heads-up and opportunity for commentary instead of being blindsided without any recourse? I was politely and patiently heard out and reassured that over time plantings of native species would restore what’s now necessarily destroyed. I was thanked for “always appreciated input from the public.”  

Bureaucracy is always better appreciated and administered with full transparency. The spokesperson weakly countered that he believed some public notice had taken place. MDOT’s press release was indeed reported in this very paper, but that came two days after my conversation with him.  

Sadly, that disappointing disconnect is about time being money and the government never has enough of either. Same holds true for most of those government serves. Why is everything’s bottom line always about economic cost? Why is “The Way Life Should Be” forever a wishful economic development spin upon the hard reality of so much of Maine’s population living hand to mouth? No wonder the majority of taxes are paid by the far more privileged few. Why couldn’t this highway’s haircut be done by way of affording the expense of looking good throughout a more incremental transformation of an even more sustained safety? Making an economized and overdue safety look good again will be a far more difficult task, especially if that goal is also done on the cheap.  

When I asked the MDOT why the questionable forestry practices so shockingly displayed needed to be so crudely accomplished, the response was that implementation was up to the discretion of the contractors. That “discretion” has little concern with avoiding offense to those that see each tree as something priceless rather than profitable and clear-cutting as a low road approach to environmental control. Sadly, the difference between the mandates of the MDOT and the MDEP couldn’t be more distinct.  

It’s said that money doesn’t grow on trees but is the root of all evil. The first part’s true, but money can bring about great good. Great wealth used to lift all boats fairly substantially if never equitably. It was great wealth that built the very same infrastructure that’s now unsustainable. Now we’re all in the same boat, at least in regards to traveling public spaces appearing more and more shabby. Many see lowering taxes as a beautiful thing, but the MDOT can only stretch its limited resources so far.  

What was once one of the MidCoast’s most charming scenic passageways will now start its recovery. Our collective quality of life is directly related to our quality of place. Some still just don’t get that. Safety’s important because life is precious. All life. Rich or poor. Plant or animal. Even fewer comprehend that. Hopefully, the MDOT can begin connecting those dots with sufficient funding to provide a less bureaucratically desperate forest management approach that can maintain both Vacationland’s safety and beauty.  

Gary Anderson lives in Bath. 

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.