One year ago, a young woman was getting ready to beat the heat with a swim in Damariscotta Lake. In a short amount of time her life would be over and the person responsible for her death is on his way to what some have called, a slap on the wrist.
Kristen McKellar was, by all accounts, a vibrant young woman. A woman who had loved her family. A woman who was keen on helping others. A woman who loved life.
Kristen was swimming near the shore of the lake on that summer day. At some point while she was in the water, a boat driven by a Massachusetts man, came at Kristen at a higher rate of speed and hit her. Kristen died of those injuries sustained in the water and the person driving the boat was charged with a handful of crimes.
The charges originally leveled in the case were manslaughter, reckless operation of a watercraft and operating a watercraft at an imprudent speed. The defendant faced a significant amount of time behind bars and a substantial fine. The case was headed to a trial. It would not have been an easy case, but sometimes you take on the tough cases because it is what is right. Then, Natasha Irving, the district attorney of Sagadahoc, Lincoln, Waldo and Knox counties pulled the plug.
The district attorney entered into a plea deal with the defendant. It is a pretty sweet deal too.
Of the original charges that were levied against the defendant only the charge of reckless operation of a watercraft remained after the plea deal. Now if the defendant completes 100 hours of community service over this coming year even that charge will be cast aside and dismissed. Ultimately the Defendant will have to pay a $400 fine for a safe boating infraction. It will be as if the accident and the taking of a life never happened.
Aren’t deferred dispositions great? Kristen’s life and the shattered lives of those she loved are only worth a $400 fine.
Natasha Irving demonstrated once again that her concerns are more for the alleged perpetrators of crimes than the victims. Why not, right? The victim is already dead so why should the D.A. worry about her.
In a prepared statement the District Attorney was quoted as saying that, “The agreement takes into account (the defendant’s) responsibility for this tragedy but also the state’s conclusion that the likelihood of obtaining a conviction at trial is extremely low.” What?
The defendant took a person’s life and he appears to be remorseful. That is admirable, but it should not absolve him of paying a significant penalty for taking that life. This individual should have lost some measure of his personal freedom after having caused the loss of all of Kristen’s freedoms. As to the case being difficult to win, is this the attitude that the D.A. takes on all of her cases? How many cases in her four counties have been dismissed because they are kind of hard?
Shouldn’t the district attorney’s office be willing to fight for the cases that are going to be tough? Shouldn’t they take on that challenge? I would hope so, but apparently when the going gets tough, the tough get to dealing. And when the tough get to dealing there is little room for justice for someone like Kristen.
In a just world the Defendant would have paid a price, at least more than a financial one, for his crimes. In a just world the District Attorney’s office would not have rolled over and played dead. In a just world Kristen McKellar would not actually be dead.
If you have committed a crime the safest place in Maine is within the jurisdiction of Natasha Irving’s prosecutorial district. The people of the four counties she represents deserve better. The family of Kristen McKellar deserve better. Kristen deserved better.
Jonathan Crimmins can be reached at j_crimmins@hotmail.com
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less