3 min read

The opinion piece on Maine’s milk pricing system (June 12,) written by Liam Sigaud contains serious inaccuracies.  Who is this writer?  What are the sources of his opinions?  Surely The Times Record could come up with a more enlightened piece on this subject. 

During my tenure as an Assistant Attorney General from 1989-2010, I served many years as counsel to the Maine Milk Commission (MMC).  The Commission is not a “quasi” government agency as asserted by Sigaum, but is a rate regulation board created by Maine statute.  

The article mis-portrays Maine as out of step with other states in continuing to regulate milk prices.  To the contrary, most states have milk prices regulated by the Federal government.  The U.S. Secretary of Agriculture sets minimum prices for milk, in regional markets, pursuant to the Agricultural Marketing Agreement Act of 1937.    

As of January 1, 2000, the Secretary reduced the number of federal order milk marketing areas from 37 to 11, through consolidation, not by elimination of any areas.  At the time, some parties contended that Maine should be included in the expanded Northeast Market.  The Secretary declined to do so stating:  “Maine has been and continues to be excluded from Federal Order regulation . . . because of its geographic separation from other areas, its long history of successful milk marketing regulation, and the limited impact of its pricing system on other regulated areas.”    

The consolidated Federal Northeast order area now includes Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Vermont, Delaware, New Jersey, the District of Columbia, and portions of Maryland, New York, Pennsylvania, and Virginia. 

The goal of Maine’s regulation is similar to the Federal system.  It is not only to guarantee price parity for Maine farmers (regardless of end use), but also to assure that Maine consumers have an adequate in-state supply of fluid milk.  The MMC also sets a minimum price on milk sold in Maine for dealers (e.g. milk processors), and for retailers.   

Advertisement

Doing away with the Commission would not guarantee lower prices for Maine consumers.  If dairy farmers were to be paid less by the dealers than the minimums set, there would most certainly be more dairy farms folding.  If we lose dairy farms and have to import milk from elsewhere, we could wind up with less available product (when supply decreases, prices increase) as well as prices driven higher by the added cost of refrigerated transportation. 

Finally, I think it is false to conjecture, as Sigaud does, that some unidentified inefficiencies of “production and distribution” at dairy farms in Maine are causing consumers to be “overcharged” for fluid milk, and that market competition among farmers would yield lower consumer prices.   

There are simply no facts to support such contentions. And, notably, the price to consumers will continue to include profit margins for dealers and retailers, over which farmers have no control. 

Lucinda E. White lives in Freeport 

Editor’s note: 

The opinion piece referenced here was written by Liam Sigaud, a former policy analyst at The Maine Heritage Policy Center. His bio on The Maine Wire reads: “A native of Rockland, Maine, he holds a B.A. in Biology from the University of Maine at Augusta and has studied policy analysis and economics at the Muskie School of Public Service at the University of Southern Maine.” 

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.