Publication of poppycock demands a response. The fanciful May 10 oped in The Times Record “It is Train Time” theorizes about reviving passenger rail between Portland and Augusta on a long-dormant right of way while ignoring actual precedent elsewhere, most notably the extension of Amtrak’s Boston-Portland Downeaster to Brunswick.
The author’s unqualified statement that “Trains provide the most cost-effective, efficient and environmentally safe form of transportation in the world” fails to recognize conditions essential to that result. Because of the extraordinary cost of building (or rehabilitating) and maintaining infrastructure to contemporary engineering standards of speed and safety, passenger rail in an exclusive corridor demands high traffic density (passengers per trip), equipment utilization (frequency of service), and public subsidy (because fares predictably will be far below operating expenses to have any hope of meeting the first two conditions). Unlike Europe, few places in this country have concentrated population centers that can generate consistent traffic in both directions on a full-day schedule.
The agency responsible for such matters in Maine, Northern New England Passenger Rail Authority, appears to be seeking further dimension for its original mission to connect Portland with Boston. There’s good reason why it does not publicize ridership at Freeport (a prominent retail destination) and Brunswick (gateway to the Midcoast region), where combined one-way trips average less than half the capacity of a motor coach for each four- or five-car train. If a market isn’t large enough to support a vehicle using public roads, it doesn’t warrant commitment to a costly fixed guideway and specialized rolling stock.
There’s a big difference between 2.5-hour Portland-Boston inter-city travel by rail and one-hour commutation serving the needs of a limited district (say greater Portland), as they involve different scheduling and equipment. Brunswick is not a logical inter-city rail terminus, but it could be an artery for rush-hour and midday access to downtown Portland. After the fact, the more frequent, flexible and economical Metro Breez bus is now testing market demand in that regard.
Commendably, NNEPRA has taken steps to promote patronage at Freeport and Brunswick, but without notable success. Though service frequency was increased from three to five daily round trips, the average passenger count per train predictably declined while the average cost per passenger increased. Fare-wise, the 28-mile Brunswick extension is an economic bargain – an adult reserved-seat costs only $1 more than a 117-mile Portland-Boston ticket, and the separate intrastate local charge can be less than $2 north of Portland with a 10-trip pass. The unfortunate reality is that most Mainers need cars to get to the train station, and it’s too easy just to keep going to Portland on their own schedules.
Neither is there demonstrable evidence of success with comparable situations in other small cities. Vermont still muses about rail commutation despite very disappointing results
with a trial service between Charlotte and Burlington. New Hampshire’s extended study of the inter-city Boston-Manchester corridor has led to increasingly discouraging cost-benefit analyses.
In Tennessee, Nashville’s “Music City Star” is experiencing steadily rising deficits that threaten its continued operation. A proposed 18-mile light-rail transit line linking Durham and Chapel Hill, North Carolina has been shelved after anticipated costs of new construction escalated to $169-million a mile. Few places offer the ideal circumstances of Texas’ 34-mile Trinity Railway Express between Dallas and Fort Worth, connecting two major metropolitan activity centers with stops in intermediate suburbs and a regional airport.
Environmentally, fuel consumption of a 4,200-horsepower diesel-electric locomotive is measured in gallons per mile (2-3, including idling time). In comparison with automobiles delivering 20 or more miles per gallon and motor coaches 8-9, near-empty trains are not helpful with respect to energy, emissions or noise.
Nonetheless, $500,000 has been committed from public sources for consultants to contrive a scenario justifying extension of Amtrak’s existing Boston-Portland route to Auburn-Lewiston. Those communities already have excellent motor coach service defining that market, so the railroad would have established competition from the outset, unlike Brunswick. The just-delivered report contemplates an investment of $275-million in plant and equipment to run 13 daily trains each way for an estimated 600 person-trips, an average of 23 riders per trip. A typical motor coach accommodates 53 passengers.
No knowledgeable politician could endorse such a predictably wasteful ‘investment” in a state with far more pressing infrastructure, commercial and social needs. While a decision is pending on Auburn-Lewiston, it is at best premature and at worst foolhardy to suggest a further foray on a parallel route to Augusta.
There are reasons to subsidize passenger transportation under certain circumstances – where population is concentrated or other options are impractical – but it is no secret that presumed operator Amtrak wants to reduce or eliminate outlying light-density routes because of its own hemorrhaging losses and equipment replacement needs, It may seem like train time to a casual observer, but transportation professionals would be hard-pressed to make a plausible case for Portland-Augusta, even though the unused line is state-owned. Physical upgrading is doable but costly, and dubious ridership potential portends an ongoing taxpayer burden for negligible benefit.
George C. Betke, Jr. is the retired President of Transport Economics, Inc., a Newcastle consultancy.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less