The flagstone of our democracy and the enduring spirit of our nation’s ethos is encapsulated in the act of voting. Lady Liberty and Uncle Sam are whispering in your ear the centuries of our nation’s progress. Election day is almost upon us. It is so close you can almost taste it, savoring the sweet flavor of freedom. And yet, for the employees of the Town of Brunswick, the day can be bittersweet.
Voting isn’t as American as apple pie. No. That is too cliche. Voting is more like an eagle flying overhead, grasping the American flag in its talons, while Bruce Springsteen sings, and fireworks explode in the background. Do I have your attention now?
While voting is considered one of the most important tenets of American democracy, so too is the ability to hold office. Most politicians begin at the local level, then work their way up to state level. From there, if they are bold enough to make the leap, they begin to eye the gleaming white marble capital of Washington, DC, resplendent in all its monumental glory. It is here at the local level though, employees of the town of Brunswick are stymied, met with a caveat.
According to the Town of Brunswick’s Personnel policy—section 12-55 Political Activity—employees of the town, who seek to hold a political appointment, and win, must resign, severing their employment with the town. Who has the ability to do that? This policy does not hinder an employee from seeking and running for office, but that “any employee elected to town office shall resign prior to taking office.” This tiny little stipulation shouldn’t really hinder any employee if they are, say, rich. If you are not independently wealthy or retired, this policy limits a citizen from having a voice in local government.
You are thinking the obvious argument; conflict of interest. Yes, but the town has that sorted out. The councilor may abstain from vote on issues with a perceived conflict of interest. The town has this outlined under; Council Rules of Order, Page 6, Duties and Privileges of Town Councilors, Conflict of Interest, 19C. “A Town Councilor shall avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest, whether there is a technical conflict or not, by disclosure of the facts underlying the potential conflict, and where appropriate, by abstaining from voting on the matter. If, after disclosure, the Councilor believes the interest will affect the Councilor’s ability to make a fair and impartial decision faithful to the public interest, the Councilor shall abstain from voting.” This seems cut and dry.
Lets face it, what person doesn’t have conflicts of interest. Here’s a few hypotheticals. Councilors might have children. It stands to reason those children might attend Brunswick’s public schools. Councilors vote on school issues. The children benefit, ipso facto there is a perceived benefit for the parents/councilors. Do those councilors abstain from all school issues because they have children in school?
What about homeownership? It is in the best interest of a homeowner to keep property taxes down. This makes fiscal and common sense. No one wants to pay more, for something they don’t have to. Councilors live in Brunswick, own homes, small businesses, maybe even investment properties. Do they abstain from discussing and voting on issues pertaining to property taxes? Personal benefit can arise from the smallest thing, even though it is not perceived as a conflict of interest. No councilor is immune to it. So why are citizens of Brunswick, that are town employees, held to a different standard? Do they not pay their taxes? Do they have less rights than their neighbor? Is their voice stymied by this archaic policy?
Community participation should be encouraged by the town of Brunswick, not hindered. A policy like this threatens taxpaying citizens rights to have a voice in their own local government. There can be checks and balances set in place to ensure a fair system, where the perceived conflict of interest is monitored. This seems already to be in place. Restricting a persons access to participate in local government does nothing but discourage taxpaying citizens from joining politics, and disenfranchising their political voice.
I hope that as you vote this week, you remember there are people in your community who are not afforded the same opportunities as you are. There are some who have much to offer, wanting to make a difference, and yet are forced to choose between employment or serving in their own local government.
I ask you, as a taxpaying citizen, would you have to give up your job to be a councilor? Why must the employees choose?
D.F. Jester is a Brunswick writer.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less