Maine’s RCV IS a model for America
Gordon Weil’s column Friday, June 29, “Maine’s RCV No Model For America,” overlooks several crucial dimensions of the RCV vote in the recent June Primary.
First, if the primary had not been run in accordance with RCV, the winner of the 7-candidate Democratic primary, Janet Mills, would have won with only 33 percent of the vote. Because of RCV she received a majority of 56 percent. She now heads to the general election with a far more unified party vote behind her. RCV clearly demonstrated its value in overcoming fractured, minority-constricted victories, something we’ve been afflicted with for decades.
Second, the campaign leading up to the primary was free of negative attacks–a lethal condition of politics today. Candidates found it made good sense to appeal for second place to voters committed to other candidates, thus refraining from slinging mud on those candidates. RCV structurally tilts candidates towards the positive rather than the negative.
Third, an RCV election relieves the voter of being burdened by the scourge of spoilerism. RCV eliminates recourse to the spoiler card and its manipulation by major parties to coerce voters.
And fourth, the June Primary gave RCV a rousing support of 54 percent to 46 percent, even greater than the 52 percent to 48 percent it received in the 2016 Referendum. This speaks volumes. Weil may think RCV is no model for America but the people of Maine think otherwise.
Because RCV has been forced out of the general election, the November contests will again be soured by the structurally builtin lure of negative campaigning and the clear possibility (given that there are four gubernatorial candidates) that we will again elect a governor with less than majority support.
We need to move to a constitutional amendment that changes the wording about electoral victory from “plurality” to “majority.” This fulfills the intent of Maine’s two state-wide votes for RCV by including gubernatorial and state Senate and House seats. We can then return in all our elections to majority rule, voter-friendly elections, and elections conducted on the issues.
John Rensenbrink
Topsham,
Co-founder, Maine Independent Green Party
Gang violence a more pressing concern
The papers are full of articles and the TV blares with reports of marches and demonstrations around the country associated with the current immigration debacle on our border with Mexico. While this is a horrible disaster and there are lives being harmed, we have another, more harmful situation going on in major cities around our country. That disaster is the continuing violence perpetrated by gangs and criminals against our fellow American citizens. In the past 14 hours, 21 people were shot (including 2 children) in Chicago.
Where are the demonstrations and public outcries against this violence? Why are the elitists and left-wing do-gooders not rioting in the streets? Why do we not see BLM or other concerned citizens groups on TV screaming about the crimes perpetrated against their fellow countrymen? Where are the media-starved politicians pounding on their chests? Where are the numerous “Reverends” calling for boycotts and marches?
I’ll tell you where — they are carefully hidden away trying to decide how they can blame all this violence on President Trump or some other leader long out of office. Isn’t it time that we, as Americans, start demanding that our elected officials actually DO SOMETHING instead of pontificating? Isn’t it time for us to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with our brave law enforcement officers instead of trying to catch the few bad apples on out cell phone cameras doing something bad? I think it is.
John Bond,
Phippsburg
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less