3 min read

I’ve been watching the current political divide. The population seems to be divided roughly into thirds. One group is avidly behind the President, his policies and his actions. Another group is diametrically opposed, opposed and repulsed at every turn. The rest … who knows?

I’m reminded of my teaching years and a time I dabbled in pop psychology. I read an article about the “early blur,” and the way it determined how difficult it was to change one’s mind, despite evidence. I read about the lab methods, found them intriguing, and decided they had application in my writing classroom.

Based on my reading, I chose a slide and put it in a projector and twisted the lens completely out of focus. It might have been, say, a water skier going off a jump with a seaplane landing behind. I had half the class step out into the hall. I then showed the remaining students a severely out of focus image and told them to write down what it they thought it was. Then I twisted the lens a quarter turn toward focus and had a couple of the “outsiders” come in. They gave their opinion of the image. Another twist, and another two opinions from the hall students.

I repeated this for as long as it took. Quarter turn, new viewers. Eventually, the newcomers would see the image clearly and accurately at first sight. But they would be the only ones. Two more would come in and verify the accurate view, and a few of the nonbelievers would convert. After a while, everyone saw the image accurately, but those starting at the “early blur” were the last to see.

I did this exercise as a writing lesson. I wanted to show my students that if in the beginning of a written work, they misled or confused the reader, they would have little chance of getting that reader back. Modestly, I think it made that point pretty well.

Advertisement

However, the researchers who studied opinion change and coined the term were not concerned with the writing of high school sophomores. They were concerned with the persistence of an impression — the early blur. Which brings us back to our population and its thirds.

It seems to me that the lens takes a quarter turn with the news every day for all of us, and sadly for our Congress. That said, the research, mine included, shows that everyone will come to the same interpretation given enough clear evidence. I never had a student indulge in denial, as in “That’s not a water skier; it’s a farmer baling hay, like I said all along.”

I singled out Congress above because they have the obligation to serve the Constitution, plus the stewardship of the public good. I think they’ve all passed sophomore English, and they are clearly above letting something hide in plain sight.

I’m not going to divulge which third I’m in, but I am confident that eventually the early blur will go away and clarity will prevail for me or fort others.

Alden Cheney lives in Bowdoinham.



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.