3 min read

Jonathan Crimmins
Jonathan Crimmins
Most of us are well accustomed to telling the truth. It is a fact of life. If you don’t tell the truth there can be consequences. Sometimes the consequences are small, sometimes they are significant. However, there are always consequences.

Anyone who has filled out tax forms knows that the truth is required. Right before you sign those yearly forms you have the line that says under the penalties of perjury you declare the form to be accurate. You tell the truth.

When you give testimony in a courtroom you have to swear or affirm that you are giving the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Seems straight forward doesn’t it. We don’t want people to knowingly lie or give false testimony to someone who is making a decision regarding a certain situation.

Wouldn’t we want the same level of trust in the court room or in the filing of tax forms or financial documents to find its way to the two houses of the Maine Legislature? Wouldn’t it be wise for our elected officials to base their decisions on information that is accurate and not a lie?

The answer for most Legislators in our area is a resounding no.

Advertisement

Last week, the Maine House of Representatives voted down LD 850, An Act to Prohibit a Person from Providing False Testimony to a Committee of the Legislature. Voted down by only one vote by the majority party in the House.

Of the 14 members of the Maine House of Representatives who represent towns within the readership of this paper, nine voted to allow lobbyists, state employees, executive branch employees and members of the public to knowingly lie and give false testimony to the Legislature. Think about this.

The body that makes laws every day just said that it is okay to lie to them. Even worse, these lies influence what is being voted on and will impact every facet of our lives.

My ability to drive at a higher speed on the highway, or your ability to use a product could be impacted. Public safety regulations, environmental issues, education policies, healthcare, taxation. Everything that Augusta legislates and controls could be built upon a foundation of intentional misinformation.

And what do we have at the Capital? Those we sent to Augusta have decided to put their head in the sand, like an ostrich, and go about their day.

Okay. So, every now and then mistakes are made. Testimony or material given to the Legislature may contain something that is inaccurate. It happens. However, the person who makes the error may not knowingly have done so. This bill was not about a simple mistake. It was about those people who intentionally mislead.

Advertisement

Surely there are some in the Legislature who would have recognized that withholding information or knowingly lying was bad. Our own Representative Tucker from Brunswick, a retired Maine District Court Judge, and someone whose life’s work was ruling on the truth, voted against this measure. I guess he will accept being lied to.

Speaker Sara Gideon surely knows that it is important to base decisions on sound reasoning and the truth, voted against this measure.

A vast majority of our elected officials in this area voted against the truth. Representatives Berry, DeChant, Tucker, Daughtry, McCreight, Cooper, Gideon, Ackley and Tepler all voted to be willfully misinformed when being given testimony. This just strikes me as being wrong. We should all hope for better.

Thankfully, there were five members of the Maine House who voted to require that lobbyists and others who testify in front of the Legislature at lease attempt to tell the truth. Representatives Pierce, Mason, Chace, Hanley and Hawke all voted to cast their future votes based on accurate and real information that is provided to them. They should be commended for this.

It would seem that some in the Legislature do not want people to have to tell the truth when they are in front of that august body. Why you ask? Well I guess if they do not require anyone to tell them the truth it makes it easier for some Legislators to lie to us.

That’s my two cents …

Jonathan Crimmins can be reached at j_ crimmins@hotmail.com


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.