On the opinion pages of The Times Record and beyond, there have been a slew of extreme right columnists coming out of the woodwork since the election of Donald Trump. Painting themselves as tell-it-like-it-is champions of an oppressed minority — the minority being “regular folk” — these anti-liberal heroes are straight-talking, anti-P.C. and determined to take their country back.
Back from whom, you ask? Liberals, of course. And anybody who is a sexual or racial minority. You know — “non-regular folk.”
It’s astonishing, really. Many columnists, in the very same breath they use to mock liberals and activists as over-sensitive and fragile, will also let readers know that those very same delicate snowflakes are big bad bullies out to destroy the lives of regular folk.
Our governor, Paul LePage, is a perfect example of this type of behavior — peppering his speeches with comments about the damage liberals cause to Mainers, vilifying them without any real evidence to back up his claims.
Another example was found on the opinion page of The Times Record on April 6 — a piece titled “Accommodating Transgender People at Expense of Others.”
The author of the piece, Christine Flowers, gave an example of a transgender boy changing their clothing in the boys locker room at school. Another boy in the locker room, who was cisgender, felt uncomfortable changing around a trans person and complained to school about it. The cisgender boy was apparently told to “deal with it.”
If a boy being told to “deal with” sharing a locker room with another boy sounds innocuous, that’s because it is. Or at least, it should be. Unfortunately whenever a cisgender person feels slight discomfort about sharing physical space with a sexual minority, a secret alarm bell goes off that alerts extreme conservative columnists to get their victim cards ready.
Flowers, apparently struck by this sordid tale of oppression at the hands of a boy changing his clothes after gym class, jumped to the nearest keyboard to let the public know that society had gone too far.
She didn’t waste any time — the very first thing Flowers tries to argue after sharing this story is this:
A cisgender child being told to tolerate a transgender boy is the same thing as a gay student being told to tolerate being bullied by a straight student.
I shouldn’t have to clarify this, but apparently this is the world we live in now. Repeat after me:
Being expected to tolerate a minority is not the same as being bullied or oppressed.
Take a moment and let that last sentence sink in. If you found yourself siding with Flowers on this issue, perhaps read it just one more time.
I really wish that the inanity of Flowers’ opinion piece stopped there. But no, there is more.
Throughout her piece, Flowers reveals a deep ignorance about both what gender is and what being trans means. At one point she insinuates that trans acceptance is a social crusade to convince children that switching genders is as frivolous as changing your hair color, trivializing trans lives. She also equates gender fluidity with the idea that gender is completely pointless, and insinuates that being trans means doing “irreparable damage to the integrity of the human being.”
By the end of the piece, she expresses that expecting children to tolerate or — heaven forbid — accept trans people essentially means the “annihilation of childhood” as we know it.
Yikes.
In Maine, unfortunately, we also face ignorance about transgender individuals from our own leadership. In 2010 LePage told an Aroostook County radio show he didn’t understand “how people, at least sane people, would want to allow transgender in our primary schools and our high schools.” In 2015, he and other governors around the country asked a federal court to block a Virginia transgender boy’s challenge of his school district’s bathroom-use policy, and in 2016 added his name in support of a lawsuit against President Barack Obama’s administration’s guidance that transgender students must be allowed to use the bathroom of their choice.
Unfortunately this sort of frightened, closed-minded fragility from members of the far right involves so much more than just the willful ignorance of their own hypocrisy. At best, their twisted tales of “normal folk” being oppressed are an attempt to maintain the status quo — but at worst, they are hate speech aimed at marginalizing and silencing already oppressed minorities.
These strange declarations about the dangers of trans people are laughable, but in this political climate, they are also chilling and sad. They show the very worst of far right conservative thought — vilification of minorities based on prejudices, fear and misinformation.
It’s time for the delicate, liberal snowflakes of the world to speak up when we see this kind of hypocrisy and maligning in our newspapers and on our televisions. We all need to stand up for sexual and racial minorities, otherwise we risk the untruths handed out by many conservatives becoming all people see.
Alicia Bane is the deputy managing editor at The Times Record and can be reached at abane@timesrecord.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less