
Hank Baumgartner can often be found reading a book on his float in Mackerel Cove, a cool salt breeze ruffling his hair as he waits for the next lobster boat to arrive and unload its catch. It’s a practice he’s perfected through the years as a lobster dealer at Glen’s Lobsters on Bailey Island, and one that — despite a down year in the industry and rumblings of lobster migrations — he doesn’t expect to relinquish any time soon.

As the 2016 lobstering season draws to a close, Maine lobstermen continue to haul their traps in hopes of landing a few more big catches before the fishing winds down this month. To try and finish strong is the hallmark of an industry with a high overhead, and this year the guys need it more than ever, as the annual lobster catch is slated to be the lowest since 2010. A strong October run is saving what could have been a catastrophe. Baumgartner thinks he knows why.

Water temperatures are paramount when considering lobster movement and shedding patterns. Cold water in the fall gets the crustaceans moving into deep water. Inversely, warm water in the summer causes them to shed in shallow water. Because of a warm winter, scientists had predicted an April shed this past spring, three months earlier than normal. Since lobstermen base their livelihoods on these patterns — when small lobsters shed their shells, many become legal in size, which kicks off the most productive portion of the season — an early shed should in theory mean a more productive season. But the predictions were anything but accurate.
“I didn’t see my first shedder until late June,” said Baumgartner. “It was a good to average July, and early August was good, and then it just stopped for six weeks.”
Steady October fishing has saved most lobstermen from going under due to expenses. High bait prices were the biggest issue. As catches dwindled in mid-August, the price of herring cut severely into daily checks, especially hurting those who invested in large boats and new traps the past few years. Mike Cota out of Pott’s Harbor in Harpswell was one of them.
“This summer I asked myself ‘why did I spend this much on a boat?’” said Cota, who owns a 40- footer, and has a 46-footer on backorder to replace it. “I’m not positive some people have made their money back. I think most of us did. August stunk, most of September stunk, but the last three weeks have saved us. I think it’ll all work out.”
Although numbers were down across the board this year, the price of lobsters remained high throughout the season. At an average of $4.50 per pound, even the poor catches of mid to late summer were somewhat insulated. But sky-high bait prices threw an additional wrench into things. Due to a shorter herring season, the price of the prized baitfish has jumped from 9 cents per pound two years ago to more than 30 cents per pound as of early October.
“Bait costs are a killer,” said Cota. “To give you an idea: last week I spent $3,500 on bait. It’s $160-$180 per bushel, and that’s for everything: red fish, pogies and herring. There are a ton of pogies in Maine. It’s like the herring price is setting the market.”
Baumgartner said he makes no money off the bait he sells to his guys on Bailey Island, but has to keep supplying them no matter the cost. No bait, no lobsters, after all.
“We have to keep the guys fishing every day,” Baumgartner said.
One silver lining was the continued low price of diesel fuel, which allows lobstermen to travel farther and run larger boats for less money.
“Guys have some seriously big boats these days,” said Baumgartner. “(The big boats) let them fish wherever they want to go. It’s safer, it’s a tax write-off. But most importantly, you buy a big boat because you can.”
Though lobstermen in the Midcoast suffered for a time this summer when the fishing dropped off, Baumgartner said Downeast Maine was hit harder.
“The people up there who were doing five pounds (of lobster) per trap the last few years went down to a pound and a quarter this August,” said Baumgartner. “They were dying.”
The guys in the Midcoast — places like Bailey Island, Pott’s Harbor, Orr’s Island and Cundy’s Harbor — haven’t fared much better.
“The fishermen who have gone hard and stayed with the schedule are going to have a good year,” said Baumgartner. “For the guys who didn’t push as hard, the expense is tough. You have to get on a schedule and stick to it.”
For a down year, Maine lobstermen still fared pretty well. Baumgartner said the average haul on any given day during the 2016 summer was 1 million pounds of lobster, more than $4 million in revenue. Seventy-five to 80 percent of that catch is sold to Canadian canneries, while a large bulk of the remainder is used for lobster rolls.
“Anywhere you go on the Eastern Seaboard and west to Milwaukee, you can find a lobster roll,” said Baumgartner. “They’re driving up the market. They’re easy to eat and the demand is strong. Lobster rolls help sustain that $4 price.”
Topping 2015’s final tally of 54.93 metric tons will be a stretch, but the price of lobsters will keep the industry in the stratosphere when compared to many other failing fisheries.
“It’s hard to predict year to year,” said Cota. “Usually you can get an idea of the season in the springtime — where you’re catching lobsters and where you’re not — but not before.”
Professor Bob Steneck, a marine biologist at the University of Maine, agrees that lobster predictions are changing all the time.
“Lobstermen are expressing some annoyance over the predictions,” Steneck said. “One lobsterman who is member of the Maine Lobster Association board said that since scientists’ predictions are often wrong, and scientists modify them, these predictions become more like observations.”
Steneck agrees that lobstermen should play a bigger role in seasonal predictions.
“It might be a better way forward if we had a kind of co-management,” Steneck said. “These guys are the eyes and ears of the industry, after all.”
Until that happens, Maine lobstermen will continue to haul their traps, and Hank Baumgartner will wait patiently to buy lobsters, book in hand, subtle grin on his face.
bgoodridge@timesrecord.com
The catch
• HANK BAUMGARTNER at Glen’s Lobsters said the average haul on any given day during the 2016 summer was 1 million pounds of lobster, more than $4 million in revenue. Seventy-five to 80 percent of that catch is sold to Canadian canneries, while a large bulk of the remainder is used for lobster rolls.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less