3 min read

HARPSWELL

A Harpswell man injured in a crash early last year has sued the drunken driver who caused the crash, as well as a handful of Brunswick restaurants and bars that may have allegedly served her alcohol while visibly intoxicated.

Benjamin Gideon, an attorney with Berman & Simmons, recently filed the lawsuit on behalf of his client, Samuel Desjardins, against Cynthia Moody, also of Harpswell.

Also named as defendants in the lawsuit are Applebee’s Neighborhood Grill and Bar, Cumberland Farms, Inc., Byrnes Irish Pub, LLC and Winner’s Sports Grill.

According to a press release issued by the Cumberland County Sheriff ’s Office after the Jan. 6, 2015, crash on Cundy’s Harbor Road, Moody, 50, was headed south on Cundy’s Harbor Road when she crossed the centerline and hit Desjardin’s northbound pickup truck head-on.

Advertisement

According to the complaint, Moody pleaded guilty to aggravated assault and operating under the influence based on her intoxication while operating a motor vehicle and the resulting collision.

Gideon said Thursday that three and a half hours after the crash, Moody had a blood alcohol level of 0.248 — which is approximately three times the legal limit.

“She did cross into my client’s lane of travel and basically hit him head-on,” Gideon said. “ There was nothing my (client) could do to avoid that. He suffered what I would call catastrophic injuries.”

He said Desjardins has a very significant leg and knee injury that required a “huge amount” of surgery and hardware, and probably will require more. A lobsterman, Desjardins may never be able to work again.

Moody is currently incarcerated, Gideon said. She had limited insurance coverage far from enough to compensate his client, he argued. It wouldn’t cover the medical bills alone, he said, which today are approaching a couple hundred thousands of dollars.

“In this case, because the other driver was so heavily intoxicated, we investigated to find out where she did her drinking and it’s our belief that she drank at one or more of the establishments that are named defendants in our case,” Gideon said. “And given how drunk she was at the time of the crash, it’s our belief that she would have been visibly intoxicated while she was being served at one or more of these locations.”

Advertisement

The Maine Liquor Liability Act imposes liability on those who serve alcohol to a person who is visibly intoxicated, and makes them responsible, up to a point, to those harmed by that intoxicated person they served, according to Gideon. The law has a cap on how much money can be recovered.

Having just filed the lawsuit, Gideon hasn’t gone through the formal process of taking testimony under oath. Due to a short statute of limitations in Maine for making liquor liability complaints, “you are often in the position of having to move forward without perfect information.”

He added, “ We have investigated and spoken with Ms. Moody, the driver, and also employees at some of the various establishments and we know she was drinking at one or more of these establishments.”

There is some competing information about exactly where and at what time she was at each one.

Maine Liquor Liability Act complaints can be challenging cases because attorneys have to prove a person was visibly intoxicated. In a situation like this where somebody’s blood alcohol is so “astronomically high” three and a half hours after, Gideon said it’s not difficult for a toxicologist to determine what her blood alcohol level would be in the hours prior to the crash.

“My hope is that if there is publicity — that will cause people who saw Moody at these locations that evening to come forward and tell us where she was,” he said.

Advertisement

Tom McKeon of Richardson, Whitman, Large & Badger represents Winner’s Sports Grill.

“We’re sure she was not served at our bar,” McKeon said Thursday. “We have no record that she was, and typically we would have.”

dmoore@timesrecord.com



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.