3 min read

Conspiracy-Theory at its Wackiest

I am writing to correct some of the major errors and blatant misinformation in the Peaceworks column of Aug. 19, “Dueling Ukraine Stories,” by Eric Herter.

First, about Russia’s illegal annexation of the Crimea. The area was inhabited by Crimean Tatars from the fourteenth century until Russia, under Catherine the Great, occupied it in the late 1700s. During World War II, Stalin deported its Crimean Tatar inhabitants to Central Asia, and only a small number returned after the war. In 1954, the Soviet government transferred it to the jurisdiction of the Ukrainian Soviet Republic. In 1991 when Ukraine declared its independence and the Soviet Union collapsed, Crimea remained part of the new Ukrainian state. As a reward for Ukrainian cooperation in securing and then giving up nuclear weapons on its soil, the U.S., European powers, and RUSSIA guaranteed the territorial integrity of Ukraine. The Russians retained their naval base at Sevastapol in the Crimea and operated there successfully for 23 years. The Russian majority population was treated fairly as citizens of Ukraine. A parallel to Mr. Herter’s defense of Russia’s annexation would be if Mexico suddenly decided to annex part of Texas because it once belonged to Mexico and a majority of citizens along the border are Mexicans. Putin’s forcible seizure of Crimea is illegal, unjustified and has properly become the basis for the US-European sanctions against Russia.

Second, Mr. Herter’s claim that NATO is threatening Russia is totally unfounded. The alliance is a collective security pact and is defensive in purpose and operation. Both the U.S. and Russia have modernized their nuclear arsenals but neither intends to use them. Herter’s assertion that we are blundering into nuclear war is reprehensible scare tactics. We have beefed up NATO forces in eastern Europe and the Baltic states not to threaten Russia but to reassure our allies there and to make sure Putin understands the cost of further land grabs against former Soviet territories.

Third, Mr. Herter’s claim that we are supporting a group of neo- Nazis in Ukraine is ridiculous. The Ukrainians have been badly misgoverned since 1991 and corruption is rife, but the change of government was motivated in large part by many Ukrainians’ desire to orient toward the West and away from Russia. Ukrainian nationalism and resentment of centurieslong Russian domination is a powerful force in Ukrainian politics. To say that greedy American “imperialists” are behind our policy toward Ukraine smacks of outof date rhetoric from the Vietnam era.

Advertisement

Fourth, Mr. Herter’s charge that the US government’s real goal in Ukraine is to unseat Putin is ludicrous in the extreme. Because of his trampling on human rights, his fostering of corruption, and his aggressive, almost jingoistic nationalism with its undertones of racism, anti-Semitism, and discrimination, most freedom-loving people in the world would like to see the back of Putin. But it clearly not a feasible objective of US foreign policy, and to believe it is smacks of conspiracy-theory at its wackiest.

Jack Thompson,

Phippsburg,

Former Foreign

Service officer,

Retired Indiana University

Professor of Russian history



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.