3 min read

The Aug. 5 Times Record carried an opinion piece by Jan Dolcater about what he perceives are the causes of decline of values in America. In his first paragraph, he alleges that the nation is in a “downward spiral in morality, personal responsibility and religious affiliation.” He then states that “many other empires and countries in history have failed for the same reasons.”

A little research into the decline of the greatest empires of the world does not support his statement. Rome, for example, was not created by God in one day and then later ruined by decaying morals and disbelief in Him. Had that been so, Edward Gibbon could have skipped the years of research and saved reams of paper writing “The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire.” He did note that the spread of Christianity contributed to the destruction of Roman morals and values, but it was only one of several reasons the empire failed. Research shows that while empires often spread religion, it was not a factor in their demise. The more common causes were over expansion of their territory and overspending on the military, perhaps a cautionary note for America.

Mr. Dolcater goes on to cite abortion, drug use and declining church attendance as causing the fall of the American empire. One problem I found is that some of his statistics are not accurate. He cites teen use of the morning after pill as now being one in five. His source, a USA Today article, states, “more than one in five sexually active teens have used the morning after pill.” One in five sexually active teens using these pills is not the same as one in five teens. Not all teens are sexually active. In fact, numerous studies show a decline in teen sexually activity from 54 percent to 47 percent in recent years. He also included abortion as an example of declining morality when actual abortion rates have been falling steadily and rapidly over the past two decades. Abortion existed before Roe v. Wade. It was legal in Colonial America and well into the middle 1800s.

There is a decline in church attendance in the 21st century, but there is no evidence connecting it with his declared decline in America’s morals or ethics. He listed the five least religious states from the 2012 Gallop polls. I considered the 10 most religious states from the 2014 Gallop polls. These states rate high on several of the FBI NCIC Crime Statistics lists. Many of these states rate as highly in crime as they do in church attendance. High violent crime, including murder of females by males, is more pervasive in these religious states than it is in our northern, “least churched” states. Another poll, from Forbes Magazine, shows that may of the most churched states have the highest poverty rates as well.

A self righteous President and a “ Christian” Congress decided that attacking Iraq, a country that had nothing to do with the events of 9/11, was OK, causing a war that killed over 100,000 Iraqis and made huge profits for Halliburton and other corporations connected to his administration. Torturing individuals we identified as being the enemy was also a fine, Christian thing to do. And the war, as many of its opponents predicted, destabilized the region and made it a training ground for groups like ISIS. I agree with Mr. Dolcater that “in many places today immorality is celebrated and not condemned.” If you consider war profiteering, torture, aborting foreign civilians’ fetuses by dropping bombs on them, and sexually degrading captured combatants to be immoral, we can see that many of or religious and political leaders are those who must be doing the celebrating.

Susan Chicketto,

Bath



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.