
Certainly, there are important differences between our two once-venerable parties. One furthers a conservative ideology. The other champions a more liberal agenda. Partisan divide could not be wider. Partisanship sees stark differences indeed.
For those to whom it matters, there’s profound importance in who wins a baseball game. To others, whether the Red Sox or Yankees win is still just another game played. Loyalties aside, both play ball as expected. There is no real gamechanger.
In our two party system today, the ballgame for power is played with bipartisan support in creating an economic caste system favoring those who have gained near complete control over marginalizing the general citizenry. Participatory democracy becomes more and more impotent. Most just sit in the stands and watch, rooting for their home team, or simply stay home altogether and wish for a viable alternative.
Some might think the Dems are the good cop, the better team. Others think them the bad one, a losing team. Similar judgments are made of the Republican’s playbook. Perhaps both sides even believe they are truly free to pursue their own branding on governing. However, whomever one roots for, little seems to change, not even the surnames of the “choices” at the top of the tickets.
Each party moves largely in lockstep, in an almost completely defensive game to goal posts that are less and less clearly marked and set further and further apart. Those fans that still show up and continue to wear team colors seem unaware that each franchise is now joint owned. Whatever remaining purity of the game might attract one to one team or the other, those owners could care less who takes home the title of victor, because, off field, in the real world, franchise profitability is theirs regardless.
People decry each party for letting big money take over the election process. Meanwhile, each party succumbs with compliant support of their own rank and file. Politicians hate constant fund raising, and being bought, but they hate losing even more. Big money is an offer few refuse.
Citizens United is all about the solidarity of the 1 percent despite their own ideological preferences. Does it really matter if our democracy is purchased by an oligarchy of the Left or the Right, or both at the same time? Does it matter if the bad cop is named Koch and the good cop is named Steyer? America rebelled against Britain, all of it, but not because the sitting king was named George. We didn’t want a different king. We wanted death to all kings.
Despite assertions to the contrary, Democrats have outgunned Republicans in big money influence of the electoral process. Importantly, however, they’ve also bested Republicans in small donor contributions. Gamesmanship is everything. One can’t lead if one doesn’t first win. “This time” the end will justify the means.
As long as big money’s power is fundamentally unimpeded, divisive Right or Left wins and losses, providing the semblance of democratic exercise, are conceded as the price of doing business. Democracy at the margins gives the 99 percent sufficient reassurance that their voice still matters, while their wealth is redistributed and their freedoms erode.
Democrats correctly point out that Republicans instinctively fight any agenda that compromises the runaway wealth of the 1 percent. Republicans respond that Democrat attempts to increase taxes on the wealthy only encourage the government in spending “Your” money, rather than the actual fact that it would redistribute “Their” money. Meanwhile, the “We,” as in “We the People,” are chump-changed. The truth is that many Dems also accommodate the 1 percent’s interest over that of “Us,” those that are getting short-sheeted whatever our politics.
Some, like me, wishfully think that improved tax fairness will somehow remedy underlying income disparity. That said, it would be a significant first step toward economic sanity.
Much is already being made of the issue of economic equality going into the warm-ups for the 2016 presidential election cycle, but, outside of Bernie Sanders, there’s no serious call for a fundamental redressing of the upward wealth redistribution that has happened over the past 40 years.
Both major parties are first and foremost about the political machine of holding on to power. And money is power — more powerful than the poorly expressed will of the people. The service of wealth eclipses all other concerns.
What remains of principled party differences? Of “family” values on the right and worker rights on the left? More and more, signature distinctions between the Dems and the Republicans have fallen away in a blood feud so polarizing that victory is sought at any cost, even if that cost is to give away the store as the price of staying in business.
———
Gary Anderson lives in Bath.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less