
Experts, hired to study and remediate hazards at a 23-acre site at Brunswick Landing that once served as a munitions disposal area, say the property is safe to be used for recreational purposes when the parcel is transferred to the town of Brunswick.
The caveat will be restrictions in the deed that prohibit digging on what is known as Site 12, located at the southeast corner of the decommissioned base that is currently fenced in.
Much of the site has already been cleaned up.
The Navy’s proposed plan went before a public hearing Wednesday night held at the Best Western in Brunswick so comments from the public could be collected and addressed in the official record of decision. A couple members of the public attended the informational meeting but no one spoke during the formal public hearing portion of the meeting. Most people attending were associated with the presentation, Midcoast Regional Redevelopment Authority or the press.
Paul Burgio, the Base Closure and Realignment Commission’s environmental coordinator for the former military base, said last week that in cases of Superfund sites, there’s a federally-required process to follow — from the initial phase of investigating any contamination to ultimately reaching a decision of record.
In this case, the Navy, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and Maine Department of Environmental Protection have all reached a conclusion about the proposed action that is suitable for the protection of health and the environment, Burgio said.
After spending three or four years at the site doing munition clearing, “we’re 100 percent confident the surface is munitions free,” Burgio said. There may still be some munitions below the surface so the Navy recommends using land use controls that will include marking the natural area space as a “no dig” area. Most of the land is going to the town of Brunswick and as part of the receipt of the deed will be a requirement that no digging is involved on the property.
After evaluating chemical contamination, taking samplings and evaluating the risk, Navy consultant Linda Klink with Tetra Tech said there is no significant risk to human health or to the environment or ecological receptors.
The site was designed as a place to detonate munition so, for the most part, the munitions were detonated inside the berms within the operation portion of the property. It was not a range where military personnel were firing artillery or grenades, for example.
“Quite a bit of work was done to remediate this site,” she said. “The entire surface has been examined and cleared of munitions items and anything that was potentially a safety risk was safely detonated.”
Soils were excavated in the 2-acre central operations area down to two feet and deeper if magnetic detectors found something lower, Klink said. The pond adjacent to the berms area was drained and cleared of any items using the magnetic detectors.
“Long story short, the Navy spent millions of dollars already doing lots of remediation and investigations,” Kirk said. When you have a munitions site, “you never can be 100 percent certain sure that there isn’t anything in the subsurface.”
According to information available Wednesday, the Navy proposes not doing additional munitions removal and implementing land use controls that would limit intrusive activity and warn site users of the potential explosive hazard present. Little additional protection would be gained through complete removal of munitions items, which comes with a $13 million price tag.
Robert Hierholzer, project manager for munitions response company USA Environmental, said the largest munitions found were inert and filled with concrete and used solely for training purposes. The majority of potential hazards found were small items, such as small fragments of demolished munitions, found in the berm area sifted and cleared. A couple 40 mm smoke grenade cartridge basins were found live, which he compared to shotgun shells, and small 20 mm projectiles were found and have been eradicated.
The proposed plan for Site 12 is available for public review at www.bracpmo.navy.mil, and also at Curtis Memorial Library in Brunswick. The Navy is accepting comments until Aug. 7. Burgio said the draft record of decision will be submitted in the next couple of weeks for another 30- day comment period. The Navy’s intent is to have the record of decision signed by the end of September, but at this time it is premature to speculate when the Navy would actually convey the property as there are several additional steps to go through.
Public comments submitted in writing must be postmarked or emailed no later than Aug. 7. Those with questions or wish to comment should contact Paul Burgio at (215) 897-4903 or fax (215) 897-4902; by email at paul.burgio@navy.mil or write to Mr. Paul Burgio, BRAC PMO East, Building 679, Naval Business Center, 4911 South Broad St., Philadelphia, PA 19112-1303.
Not a range
THE SITE WAS DESIGNED as a place to detonate munition so, for the most part, the munitions were detonated inside the berms within the operation portion of the property. It was not a range where military personnel were firing artillery or grenades, for example.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less