
To its enemies, the government of Venice seemed dominated by unimaginative old men who spent most of their time working in committees. There was no army or navy except for its citizens. There was no police force except night watchmen. The country called itself a republic and yet the commoners could not vote for the people who led them.
And still the people of Venice were happy. They loved their city and clung desperately to their old neighborhoods and institutions. Whenever the Republic was threatened, they turned out in force to defend it.
What made Venice so special?
One answer may lie in the way Venetians used capitalism to benefit the whole community.
Venetians were first and foremost merchants and manufacturers. Nobles engaged mainly in maritime trade and finance, whereas commoners engaged mainly in manufacturing.
Before the industrial revolution replaced people with machinery, both of these activities required many skilled workers, and these men were highly valued in Venice for their contributions to society.
Maritime trade complemented the manufacturing sector by ensuring that master craftsmen had access to the finest raw materials as well as markets for their products throughout the world.
Venetians had no use for free trade agreements because the purpose of business was enrich the whole community, not just oneself. Thus, there was no hiring of foreign workers or outsourcing of jobs to other countries.
On the contrary, the Venetians regarded their city as a commune. All citizens were expected to share in the risks and rewards of common effort.
The government regulated the economy as needed to ensure prosperity and economic opportunity, but no more than was useful.
For example, the government required that cargo be carried on well-armed government vessels if the danger of attack by enemies along a trade route was high. However, if a trade route was relatively safe from attack, cargo could be carried on privately owned vessels, so long as they conformed to Venetian maritime laws on crew size, pay, armaments and other vital matters.
One of the reasons that government ships were used for voyages to high value destinations was to ensure that budding capitalists would have access to markets. In essence, by law, all Venetian merchant ships were to act like common carriers, much like railroads in the United States. No one was to be excluded from the service merchant ships provided so long as the customer could pay the cost of the freight.
Americans would be stunned by how well the labor force was organized for its own protection.
Most commoners who were not domestic servants, concubines or ordinary seamen were organized into guilds. There were two kinds.
Worker guilds were similar to labor unions in the United States. They represented laborers in many industries where the members worked for other people. The largest worker guilds in Venice were shipbuilders and woolen workers.
Trade guilds represented independent businessmen who employed a combination of unskilled laborers and apprentices in small shops. Generally, they were master craftsmen in such industries as glass blowing, jewelry- making and stone work. Typical shops in Venice employed six to twelve people.
The guilds operated much like small governments. Administrators equivalent to a Board of Selectmen were elected by the members to manage the guild for terms of a few years. Major policy decisons were decided at meetings of the whole membership held about once or twice a year.
The guilds negotiated for decent wages, collected dues to pay for social security and worker’s compensation benefits and parceled work out fairly among the membership. Trade guilds even purchased raw materials for their members to lower costs and improve the quality of manufactured items.
The Venetian government regulated the guilds only to the extent necessary to ensure honest accounting of finances and to prevent price gouging of customers.
It also provided to some extent for the needs of the apprentices and unskilled laborers employed in the shops of master craftsmen.
The three main directives in this policy were an abundant food supply, decent wages and the ability to start businesses on their own for those who qualified. In order to ensure access to work, trade guilds were prevented from unduly restricting the number of apprentices who could rise to the level of master craftsman.
To keep its skilled work force, the government of Venice assured all citizens regardless of rank that everyone was equal before the law. If someone was accused of a crime, and they were too poor to hire a lawyer for defense, the government would assign one at public expense to represent them.
Modern historians question just how equally justice was applied in Venice, knowing how unequal justice is here in the United States, but the working people of Venice must have decided that the opportunities were worth the risk. The Republic never had difficulty in recruiting skilled workers for its industries and never suffered a revolt against the government by ordinary people during its long history.
Indeed, the only revolts in Venice were organized by members of the aristocracy seeking a dictatorship or a monarchy. Although these incidents were rare, in each case they were stopped by a coordinated effort of commoners and nobles.
In 1310, an ambitious young noble tried to sieze power by force in an early morning attack upon the ducal palace. He was stopped in the streets by a formation of woolen workers with weapons and armor. He attacked with his men and the woolen workers executed him on the spot.
In 1354, a doge tried to install a monarchy one month after being chosen to lead the country by the Great Council. He was hunted down and beheaded in public. Nobles held up his head and shouted to the crowd that justice had been achieved.
Both of these incidents occurred during the turbulent years of the fourteenth century, a time of disease and war that ravaged Europe and strengthened the hands of dictators and monarchs even in freedom loving lands like Italy.
Nonetheless, by a show of strength and unity, the Republic of Venice survived. By the year 1400, it was the only country left in Europe where ordinary people enjoyed prosperity and justice based upon a unique form of representative government.
———
Gary Fogg lives in Topsham.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less