The death last November of Brittany Maynard, a 29-year-old woman suffering from a terminal brain tumor, has generated much press and many debates on the right to die with dignity. (See Time Magazine, Jan. 29, and the New York Times, Jan. 31, “Dying Shouldn’t Be So Brutal” op-ed piece by Dr. Ira Byock)
With today’s more debilitating, medically-prolonged illnesses, a perfect death is an exception. Death with dignity laws, now enacted in several states and in draft form in many others, allows patients the option to die at a time of their own choosing. While palliative care and/or hospice care has greatly improved, good care and a patient’s option to end life can certainly co-exist, integrating compassion and respect for the patient’s autonomy and ultimately making death with dignity a real option. The final decision rests only with the person facing death. Why should anyone — the government, the medical profession, or anyone else — have the final say in how another person dies?
Opposition to physician aid in dying runs counter to our basic humanity — self-reliance and determination, individual choice and free will. It is unethical to deprive these rights from individuals at the end of their lives. Under the Hippocratic Oath, doctors are to ‘do no harm.’ Does ‘not doing harm’ mean to prolong a life that has become a painful burden? The role of the physician is not to prolong life at all costs, but to reduce suffering and improve the quality of life if and when they can; physician aid in dying is not incompatible with this goal.
Opponents claim that it is a recipe for elder abuse and threatens the lives of people with disabilities. These allegations are based on unsubstantiated information as there has been no documentation that this has happened since the first Death with Dignity Act went into effect 15 years ago. Also, religious beliefs should not be used as an excuse to deny anyone an informed death with dignity; to deny this option is unethical, holds others hostage, and is in direct opposition to the separation of church and state.
The death with dignity laws enacted and the proposed legislation (with slightly different wording in each state) mandate that competent, terminally ill adults, at least 18 years old and a state resident, must be diagnosed with a terminal illness. They must state, orally and in writing, their wish to end their lives. Patients must submit this written request, witnessed by two persons, for medication (there is a waiting period for the prescription or medication). Patients must be physically capable of administering the drugs themselves.
No one other than the patient — not physician, nurse, pharmacist, family, friends — is required to participate under this law; the choice is optional. It’s interesting to note that in states where it is now legal, many patients have not used this option; just knowing they have a choice brings comfort.
So there needs to be the release from civil or criminal penalties of those who, under these strict and proper safeguards, act to honor the right of terminally ill patients to select the time of their own deaths. Legislation is now being drafted in Maine. Let’s hope our elected officials will see fit to follow the examples set in Oregon, Washington, Vermont, and the many states which are currently moving forward with legislative efforts this year. Years of data show that Death with Dignity laws work the way they are intended and offer protection for all people. True compassion in dying is to accept the right of human beings to ask for assistance and decide for themselves how their lives will end. This is a very personal and difficult choice.
Nan March
Brunswick
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less