4 min read

Editor’s Note: The opinion essay below wa written last fall by 11th grade students as assignments for the Critical Reading & Writing English Lab course at Mt. Ararat High School. Students were asked to articulate their opinion on a topic of importance to them in a way that might also engage local readers. Over the next week, we will be running more of these student opinions, allowing their perspectives to be heard by a larger audience.

Divine or Detriment?

I’ve noticed that many people dislike organized religion in general. Some people blame organized religion for most of history’s killings. It’s also sometimes said that more people have been killed in the name of God than for any other reason (war, sickness, etc). This is why I argue that religion has caused more harm than good.

A lot of people say the religion may have caused harm, but it’s caused plenty of good, too. And that is true; religion has caused plenty of good. Like giving people faith through hard times, explaining why there’s lighting in the sky, or being a reason for why a loved one may have died. The only thing wrong with all of that is we have science now. The purpose of science is to explain, with reason, why there’s lighting in the sky or why a loved one may have died — to show us the real world. My point is, a lot of the good caused by religion isn’t even there. The good caused by religion is usually just an illusion. Even so, in your head religion may cause good and inspire you, but when it comes to the real world it’s just the reason behind a lot of crazy things. Such as slavery.

Slavery was really the start of religion causing harm in our country. The South wanted to keep their slaves for profits and a lot of the time, the reason they would give was that it was the way God wanted it to be. That God made them be slaves. Back then, slavery was considered a legal matter, and the fact that religion was tied into it as an excuse just made it harder to abolish, eventually causing more deaths of innocent people.

Advertisement

Another deadly event in history caused by religion was the Holocaust. This one is pretty selfexplanatory. Millions of people were killed simply because they identified as Jewish or with a religion. I’m going to explain why religion is at the heart of these deaths. Because religion is such a big deal in society and has been for so long, it has prominent meaning. And with that meaning and importance, you’ll get people who like it, and who don’t like it. Obviously, Hitler didn’t like a certain religion, and because religion is so important to society, he wanted to eradicate it. Religion has such a big influence on the decisions we make in society. The Nazis felt that Judaism didn’t belong, and they killed. But if we didn’t define ourselves by religion, if it didn’t define us, then stuff like this wouldn’t happen. Religion wouldn’t cause millions of deaths.

The last religion-based event I’m going to talk about is September 11th. I know this may be a sensitive subject for people, especially Americans, but it’s the perfect example of religion causing death. Now I’m not saying all Islamic people are terrorists, not at all. In fact, I think it’s the way America reacted to this event that caused a lot of problems. When the terrorists’ attacks against America happened on September 11th, the majority of Americans panicked. The anti-Islam rebellion coursed through America.

The problem with this is that one group of people hates another group of people because of how they identify when how they identify has nothing to do with the 9/11 attacks. In fact, Islam is closer to Christianity than it is to 9/11, simply based on the backstories of their religions. That’s why this hatred is so bad, and also why religion is to blame. If we didn’t have religion, or it wasn’t so important, then we’d realize those terrorists didn’t attack us because they’re Muslims; they did it because they’re terrorists.

Now I’m not trying to use all of this to suggest we eradicate religion. But it shouldn’t be tied in so heavily with our beliefs and how we look at things logically. My idea revolves around changing the idea of religion by making it fit society in a more beneficial way, to prevent deaths that don’t need to happen. Religion is still causing millions of deaths today, but it doesn’t have to.

Adam Sirois



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.