3 min read

The Coventry Carol is one of the oldest Christmas season carols that we know about. It wasn’t written for Christmas, though, but for a feast day three days later, the Feast of the Holy Innocents.

The song opens with a haunting lullaby, sung by nuns:

Lully lulla, thou little tiny child, bye, bye lully lullay

Oh, sisters too, how may we do, for to preserve this day?

This poor youngling for whom we do sing, bye, bye, lully lullay…

Advertisement

It was written for a mystery play, a pageant by a couple of guilds in Coventry, England, in the 1500s. It goes on to describe the mass slaughter of the children of Bethlehem, ordered by Herod, after the Holy Family escaped to Egypt.

The lullaby is an attempt to sing their souls to sleep, in remembrance on each December 28.

No one really knows if the slaughter of the Holy Innocents really happened.

But we do know that a modern-day slaughter of the innocents happened two years ago this week.

The Bethlehem mothers and children had no defense against Herod’s swords. Nor did the children of Sandy Hook and their teachers have any defense against Adam Lanza’s gun.

But before you suggest that the teachers should have been armed, really give it some rational thought. Do we want assault rifles hanging on the coat hooks in a kindergarten classroom? Do we want the kind of society that makes it necessary for teachers to blow the heads off teenagers or young adults who menace them, whether they are mentally disturbed or not? Is that the kind of society we really want?

Advertisement

Do we want our children to see that?

Nancy Lanza cared deeply about her son Adam. She cared enough to pull him from a school that wasn’t providing what he needed and schooled him at home. She knew there was something profoundly wrong with Adam; when a caregiver looked after him, she warned the caregiver never to let Adam out of his sight.

She also, however, legally bought handguns and an assault rifle, which she enjoyed using for target practice. Maybe it helped her with the stress of having a special needs young adult son. It’s hard to know.

But then one day, Dec. 14, 2012, Adam took her toys and decided to play, too. He first shot his mother multiple times, then took the guns over to a nearby elementary school and calmly, systematically, killed 20 children and six adults, before taking his own life.

When we first heard about the possibility of a school shooting on that awful day, we knew what the outcome would be. So did everyone else. The perpetrator would turn out to be a white, middle-class adolescent boy or young man, a loner who played video games, someone with legal access to enormous firepower, someone with a mental illness that should have prevented him from having access. He would commit suicide. He’d manage to take several innocents along with him. No one would ever know why he did it, or his reasons would seem so wild that they wouldn’t make sense to sane people.

There are no reasons that make sense.

Advertisement

We’ve seen this film before. We’d seen it 18 times in 2012 alone. We’d seen it 61 times since Columbine. And sadly, we’ve seen it many times since.

When does the Feast of the Holy Innocents end?

Lully, lulla, thou little tiny child, bye, bye, lully lullay.



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.