5 min read

ABOVE: MEMBERS OF the Freeport High School Mock Trial Team include, back row, from left, Hank Ogilby (teacher), Cassie Parker, Taylor Schenker, Chloe Whittaker, Ethan Pierce, Erik Ly, Simon Handelman and Karen Massey (founder of program/former teacher/cooperating attorney), and, front row, Elizabeth Kolle, Ella Russell, Abigail Gray and Eamon Reis. Missing from the photo are Abigail Smith and Bill Browder (cooperating attorney).
ABOVE: MEMBERS OF the Freeport High School Mock Trial Team include, back row, from left, Hank Ogilby (teacher), Cassie Parker, Taylor Schenker, Chloe Whittaker, Ethan Pierce, Erik Ly, Simon Handelman and Karen Massey (founder of program/former teacher/cooperating attorney), and, front row, Elizabeth Kolle, Ella Russell, Abigail Gray and Eamon Reis. Missing from the photo are Abigail Smith and Bill Browder (cooperating attorney).
FREEPORT

ETHAN PIERCE, Chloe Whittaker and Abigail Gray review materials.
ETHAN PIERCE, Chloe Whittaker and Abigail Gray review materials.
T he rise of the Freeport High School Mock Trial

Team has required more than energy drinks and weekend practices — it’s taken a dedicated cadre of students, faculty and volunteers to build a tight-knit, competitive group.

On Saturday, the mock trial team is headed to the Cumberland County Courthouse in Portland for the statewide competition’s semi-finals. The 11-member team will go head-tohead against a team from Brewer High School, while teams from Cape Elizabeth and Casco Bay high schools duke it out in another courtroom.

The mock trial team is composed of members of FHS teacher Hank Ogilby’s Topics in Social Sciences class, which is open to all grades at the high school. Retired attorney Bill Browder and former attorney and FHS teacher Karen Massey have also coached the team.

Advertisement

Massey, who retired at the end last school year, taught the team for the previous 17 years before Ogilby volunteered to continue the course this year.

“It is essentially learning the practice of law — the rules of evidence, how to prosecute a case and how to defend somebody,” said Ogilby. “The kids have to prepare both sides of the case and they each have to take on two or three roles, and when we go to trial we argue both sides.”

The trials take place in courthouses with actual justices presiding over the cases, which have been given to the competing teams by the Maine State Bar Association. Attorneys judge the competing teams, said Ogilby, and the morning starts with a coin toss that determines which team will start as the prosecution and which will start as the defense.

“It’s a fictitious case — this one is about a high school situation with bullying and an assault,” said Ogilby. “We’ll run through the trial, which might take two hours, and then after a break we’ll switch sides and run through it again, which may take another two hours.”

It’s a grueling competition, but the lead-up to the trials requires just as much commitment and fortitude as the actual trial, according to the mock trial team — or maybe more.

“The most challenging part is in the beginning,” said Abigail Gray, a senior at FHS who has been on the mock trial team for three years in a row. “Initially there is just so much information to process, but it’s also the most exciting because you’re developing your theory of the case.

Advertisement

“This is the fun part now,” she said. “Now we discover new things every day and we get to practice.”

“There is definitely a learning curve,” said Chloe Whittaker, a senior at FHS. “I had no idea what mock trial was when I took the class, so I had no idea how much it involved.

“It was really hard to learn to convert the thoughts in your head into lawyer-speak and how to make it sound intelligent while getting your thoughts across in the way that is acceptable,” she added. “Once I was able to do that it was a lot more fun and I realized that this is the best class at Freeport High School because it teaches you so much more than how to try a case.”

“It’s really a team sport and one of the things that was hardest for me was the time commitment,” said FHS senior Erik Ly. “You’re only as good as the time and effort you put in. You can be brilliant and a quick thinker, but that doesn’t mean anything in mock trial if you’re not willing to sacrifice a good part of your schedule to practice.”

The class runs for 90 minutes every other day during the school week, said Ethan Pierce, a junior at FHS. In addition to that, students meet regularly on Sunday mornings for four-hour practice sessions and have also met for dinner practices.

“The more I do this, the more I realize how heavily each part relies on the other,” said Pierce. “Even beyond a witness and a direct examiner, everyone is so interdependent — that’s where the time commitment comes in handy.

Advertisement

“Getting up at 6 o’clock on a Saturday morning to spend four hours in a courtroom, for me it’s not like ‘Yes! 6 o’clock! Courtroom!’” said Pierce. “But the trials and the practices bring us closer together as a team.”

When they hit a wall at practice, Red Bull, coffee and doughnuts can help them push through, the team said, but so does the knowledge that their teammates depend on them.

“Mock trial teams are a well-oiled machine,” said Ly. “Every cog, every component needs to work perfectly and at the same level. If we had nine people operating at 100 percent and one person at 90 percent — it’s going to show.”

Despite the pressures, however, mock trial has built the team members confidence, and even inspired some of the team to pursue law careers, like mock trial veteran Gray.

“We’re really lucky to have this as a class — a lot of schools don’t,” said Gray. “This program almost didn’t continue after Ms. Massey retired last year, and I was worried that it would be the last year, but then Mr. Ogilby offered to teach the class.”

“In the trials, there are moments when you surprise yourself,” said Whittaker. “When you think ‘Wow, I had no idea I was capable of doing that — I just sounded so cool and so smart.’

Advertisement

“That rush that you get when you do something you didn’t think you’re capable of fuels you to keep going.” she said. “The harder you work, the more often those moments happen and the better you feel about yourself.”

Members of the mock trial team are not only excelling in an academic setting, said Ogilby, they’re gaining valuable life skills.

“I think a lot of kids might say they like to argue, but these kids need to learn to argue based on facts and evidence and the rules of law,” said Ogilby. “It’s not just arguing, it’s learning to argue carefully and thoughtfully.

Following the semi-finals this Satuday, the final competition will take place on Wednesday, Dec. 17.

rgargiulo@timesrecord.com


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.