7 min read

DONALD SOCTOMAH is seen here carving a canoe rib for a birchbark canoe.
DONALD SOCTOMAH is seen here carving a canoe rib for a birchbark canoe.
History, as taught in U.S. history books, showcases a view of Thanksgiving given to us by the settlers who fought to survive after their arrival in America.

But Thanksgiving brings up more emotions among Native Americans, the indigenous people already living on this land and who were responsible for helping the pilgrims avoid perishing. To them, it marks a turning point in the relationship with the European immigrants who had come here.

While they shared a meal — with food provided by the Native Americans — and fellowship at the first Thanksgiving, it wasn’t long before the white people settling in America set about to indoctrinate the native people in their mold. The result: Devestation of an entire culture.

NORMAN BERNARD, right, poses for a photo with his wife, Judy Ann Bernard.
NORMAN BERNARD, right, poses for a photo with his wife, Judy Ann Bernard.
In speaking with a few Native Americans who are part of tribes in Maine, one can see how difficult it can be to balance giving thanks for health and family with knowing the eradication of many indigenous peoples began shortly after the events celebrated in the U.S. every year.

Donald Soctomah served as tribal representative for the Passamaquoddy Tribe for eight years and is currently the tribal historic preservation officer. He said Thanksgiving is a tough issue to talk about.

Advertisement

“It makes us think about how people can start off with a sit down and have a meal on good terms and then something really destructive happens,” Soctomah said. “For me, personally, it’s a time to give thanks for what we have, for our family, and give thanks for togetherness.

“But, when it comes to the history part, it’s sad, because the tribes that did sit down with them on the first meal, they really suffered,” he added. “War and disease, taking of land, and other stuff you don’t really like to think about.”

Soctomah said a lot of Native American families come together on Thanksgiving.

“It gets us ready to celebrate what we have today, friends and family,” he said, adding that was Native American tradition before what the U.S. history books teach as the “first” Thanksgiving. “For the tribes, in the fall, families would sit together after a big harvest or big hunt, they would sit together, a brotherhood for the tribes to sit down with big meals like this.

“Today, it sort of is, too. Families come up and visit, they stay in the community. It’s sort of bringing families back for the fall harvest,” added Soctomah. “But the history part of it is really sad; most tribal people don’t want to talk about it.”

During Soctomah’s childhood, Thanksgiving had a different meaning.

Advertisement

“When I was little, Thanksgiving meant we were going to have a good meal,” said Soctomah. “I was raised on a reservation, and when I was going to grammar school at Pleasant Point in the late-’50s and early-’60s, our community was pretty poor. We had an income of around $500 a year, on average.

“School time was the one good meal we’d have, pretty much, during the day,” he added. “So, at Thanksgiving, they brought the turkeys out and that was a treat.”

Norman Bernard, an elder and spiritual leader with the Aroostook Band of Micmacs, agreed that most Native Americans celebrate Thanksgiving, acknowledging it creates “mixed emotions, for sure.”

“Some of the stories I heard, everybody heard about the feasts — feasts and food are one of the things we always shared — we were very open and welcome on the East Coast,” he said. “So then there’s the story about the day after, the onslaught of slaughter that took place.

“Some people remember history and want to talk about it in that way, but most of the native families I know, we celebrate Thanksgiving — it’s a feast,” added Bernard.

His family celebrates the day like most others in the U.S.

Advertisement

“We cook a big turkey and have a big old feed. If family shows up, great. If not, great. We have turkey and mashed potatoes, my wife likes yams, we have cranberries,” he said. “As for the Native American part, I can’t say if we’re following any ways. Every time, in the Native American way, we have a ceremony, there’s always a feast. There’s something about sharing that food.

“That’s what happened with the very first Thanksgiving, it was a big feast, with wild turkey, vegetables,” Bernard added. “Everything they ate for that feast was from the land.”

In Native American tradition, a harvest feast celebrated the end of that season and acknowledged the one to come. That holds true today when it comes to the time around the Thanksgiving holiday.

“It’s sort of our reminder that winter’s right around the corner,” Soctomah said. “People get their houses ready for the long winter, they start getting food — much like our ancestors did this time of year.”

Despite the fact Native Americans clearly knew how to thrive on these lands long before Europeans arrived on the shore, the new settlers attempted to show them a “better” way to live.

“The tribe looked at the forest land as home, the forest provided everything for the tribe. If you take care of the forest, it takes care of you,” said Soctomah. “When the Europeans came, they looked at the forest as a resource. That was against our concept of land.”

Advertisement

“If you think about overseas, there at that time frame: What was their mentality?” Bernard added. “A lot of it was trade, power, control, money. When they discovered this new land, which was already occupied, that’s what they brought with them.”

Once the settlers set their sights on civilizing the indigenous people living here, the attitude permeated the new American culture. Thus created a clash between the conservation and consumption attitudes, bringing with it actions designed to eradicate the culture — and many lives — of Native Americans.

Native American children were taken from their homes, Bernard said, and placed in residential schools that worked to strip their ancestral culture from them. Parents who objected were jailed.

“The first thing that happened was all kids got haircuts; native people had long hair,” Bernard said. “If you spoke the language, you were punished.

“A lot of the elders, because that was forced upon them, that’s the way they learned,” he added. “It is a tough subject for some. I try not to focus on the bad.”

But it is clear Bernard does not forget history.

Advertisement

“We endured slaughter, germ warefare; they say it wasn’t intentional — we believe it was,” he said. “We lost somewhere between 95- 98 percent of our people.

“Then you take the encampments, we were subject to live in a certain area. If you were caught outside that territory, you were shot on sight,” Bernard added. “If you look at the term ‘Redskin,’ that’s from scalping. A lot of people believe the natives started that, but it wasn’t.”

He elaborated that “redskin” was the term used to identify the scalps of Native Americans taken by white people.

“If you look at American history and the treatment of Native Americans, it’s an eyesore,” Bernard said. “If you listen to the elders when they’re speaking, they remember their childhood when they were taken out of their homes and put in residential schools.”

While he knows words from his tribe’s language, Bernard isn’t able to speak it. His mother was in the schools and learned that when she spoke her native tongue, she’d get a beating.

“When I was younger, she talked about how she used to be able to speak it,” Bernard said. “Every time we walked in the woods, she used to point out this and that, the little that she knew. She was giving me the teachings of some of our medicines. She didn’t put it that way, but she remembered.

Advertisement

“We have survived, because we adapted,” he added. “You had a choice: Do it this way or you’re going to perish. Sometimes you do what you need to do to survive.”

Given the efforts throughout United States history against them, it would be hard to fault Native Americans for holding on to anger. However, that’s not the path Bernard chooses to take. Instead, he relies on his roots to grow stronger, expressing gratitude every day — not just one day a year — and embracing Native American spirituality.

“It’s all about balance within ourselves,” Bernard said. “Mentally, we clear our minds, spiritually, we pray for positive and good, so we have a good outcome.

“We give thanks for the day and the feed and family and health, all the good things,” he added. “Like anything else, live for today, live for tomorrow.”

rmontana@timesrecord.com


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.