3 min read

Sen. Angus King did as he said he would and cast the pivotal no vote on the Keystone XL pipeline on Tuesday evening. The measure failed by just one vote — presumably King’s, since he is the Independent — with 14 Democrats joining with Republicans in favor of the pipeline.

There are thousands of reasons why the XL Pipeline is a bad idea. Here are just a few:

. Digging out and heating up the tar sands to obtain the oil produces three times more greenhouse gas than ordinary sweet crude processing.

. The sludgy oil sands oil is highly corrosive and damages pipelines much worse than ordinary oil, making them more likely to spring leaks underground. . The XL Pipeline is planned to be right on top of the Ogalala Aquifer, one of the only sources of clean, fresh water in the plains states.

. Cleaning up tar sands oil is practically impossible. Once it’s in a water system, it can virtually never be completely cleaned up.

Advertisement

. Once the very temporary construction work is complete, there will be a total of 45 new jobs related to the pipeline. Hardly a “job creator.”

. The oil will not be used in the U.S., but will be shipped to Asia and other locations around the world. It will do nothing for our balance of trade, or keep us from buying light sweet crude from “unfriendly” nations such as Venezuela and Saudi Arabia.

. It could start a war with a sovereign native nation, the Rosebud Sioux.

There are more reasons, but these should suffice.

King has done the right thing.

His no vote will scuttle the supporters’ effort to move the bill through the Senate, at least this year. King expressed frustration that President Obama has not been more forceful on the bill. Obama should make a decision — the review has gone on long enough — and the answer seems fairly clear: Keystone XL is a bad deal for the U.S., and the planet.

Advertisement

All 45 Senate Republicans voted for the bill, including Sen. Susan Collins. Her record on the environment is mixed, but she has voted about 68 percent of the time in favor of environmental protection. However, she voted for passage of the John Hoeven amendment in 2012, which would have asserted that no additional safety or environmental analysis needed to be done on the pipeline. It required 60 votes to pass, and failed to get that number. In 2013, Hoeven proposed another amendment that was a nonbinding resolution, supporting the construction of the pipeline. It passed, but went no further.

King voted against the 2013 Hoeven resolution.

Whatever happens now, it is up to Obama to get off the fence and lead on this issue. Part of the problem Democrats have faced is an inability to grow a spine and keep it upright. With the midterms disastrously behind him, this is as good a time as any for Obama to do so.

Of course, Republicans will bring the bill back once new members take office in January, when they will have the majority. Sen. Mitch McConnell, R-Kentucky, who is set to take over as majority leader, said as much following the failed vote last night. That will force Obama to take up the veto pen — hopefully something he’ll stand up for and do.



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.