
Proponents of two groups representing opposing positions on the question of Freeport’s withdrawal from Regional School Unit 5 were at loggerheads at a public hearing Tuesday night, which ended with town council members voicing their personal leanings.
Of the seven-member council, six stated they would be voting “Yes” on Question 1 on the November election ballot, favoring a withdrawal from RSU 5 which currently is comprised of Durham, Freeport and Pownal.
Members of the citizen groups Yes For Freeport, in favor of withdrawal, and Better Together, who favor continuing in the RSU, as well as resident speakers not party to any coalition, were divided a little more evenly on the topic.
In the packed town council chambers, residents lined up to the door for a chance to voice their opinion. Roughly 11 speakers supported a “No” vote and 17 spoke in favor of a “Yes” vote, with a majority favoring withdrawal.
Yes For Freeport members cited dropping enrollment numbers, which they speculated is owing to sub-par programming compared to regional, private and charter schools, the sonamed “RSU 5 budget wars” over school improvement bonds, and overcrowded classrooms and facilities among other reasons they supported withdrawal.
Better Together members countered by citing diverse programming offered in RSU 5 schools and class sizes that met the state average, the benefits of a larger a student body in terms of sports performance and socialization, and the risk of potential tax increases associated with withdrawal among other reasons they supported remaining in the RSU.
A recent withdrawal financial analysis provided by the town of Freeport sought to assess what the impact on Freeport’s tax burden would have been during the current fiscal year if Freeport had withdrawn under the terms of the proposed withdrawal agreement for the 2014-15 school year.
The analysis gauged that Freeport could have saved as much as $288,876 operating as a standalone district this year, if Durham and Pownal students attending Freeport schools had paid tuition.
The analysis further noted that with the loss of 60 of the total 238 students from Durham and Pownal, Freeport’s tax burden could have increased approximately
$343,695.
An independent analysis compiled by three former Freeport town council chairmen, Rod Regier, Fred Palmer and Ed Bradley, concluded that the town could face an additional tax burden of $611,899 if the town votes to withdraw.
“I have been very adamant that we try to remain as neutral as possible through this process,” said current town council chairman Jim Hendricks, in response to a request from the public that the council members state how they would vote on the withdrawal issue.
Hendricks cautioned against giving “undue weight” to the personal opinions of councilors, but said he would be voting in favor of withdrawal.
“I really do feel that the governance model that we’re in now with the RSU is not ideal for me,” said Henricks. “This has nothing to do with the towns of Pownal or Durham — I hope we still continue to have a great relationship with those towns. It’s more for me about regaining local control of our schools.”
Vice chairwoman Kristina Egan said she thought withdrawal would be a mistake for Freeport, and added that she has previously voiced this opinion to constituents and in a letter to the editor published Oct. 7 in the Tri- Town Weekly.
“I’ve looked at the numbers and I’m compelled to think that we have a very rosy scenario,” said Egan, “expecting Pownal and Durham students to come to Freeport if we say we don’t want them to be a part of the governing structure.
“I feel like it’s a bad deal for the taxpayers and a bad deal for our kids,” she said.
Councilor Andy Wellen said he would be voting in favor of withdrawal owing to the results of school budget votes which have often been divided along town lines over the previous five years.
“Pownal and Durham seems to vote differently overall, so it appears as if overall Freeport residents have different priorities than Pownal and Durham,” said Wellen. “By withdrawing I believe Freeport will be able to create more of what we want in a school system while still cooperating with Pownal and Durham.”
Councilor Sarah Tracy said she identified three key considerations in deciding to vote “Yes” in favor of withdrawal: the quality of education, relative cost of operation, and long-term benefits of governing as a standalone district rather than a member of the RSU.
“I believe Freeport can provide a better quality of education in a Freeport-only school district,” said Tracy. “What I have seen over the past five years are barebones budgets that demonstrate an attitude of reluctance to make needed investments in our school system.
“I believe that if we are relieved of the weight of significant opposition to investment by the other communities,” said Tracy, “that we have the opportunity to make smart, prudent, longterm investments in funding education and improving our infrastructure to distinguish our school system.”
Councilor Melanie Sachs said she is “100 percent” in favor of voting “Yes” for withdrawal.
“Sound and strategic fiscal management I believe is better in the administrative model of a standalone (district),” said Sachs. “I believe that sustainable vision is better in a Freeport standalone model.
“My heart says that the kids will flourish, the kids will be fine” if Freeport withdraws, she said.
“From the very beginning when we created the RSU, the cost-sharing model was flawed and unfair; I didn’t support it then and I don’t support it now,” said Councilor Rich Degrandpre, who also said he would be voting “Yes” in favor of withdrawal.
“Freeport is paying for a larger share of kids than we put in the system,” he said. “Going forward, the bond that’s already passed, the repayment of that bond uses the same cost-sharing model.”
“I am also voting for withdrawal,” said Councilor Scott Gleeson. “I believe that the major question here has always been about local control and how we as a town wish to manage our school system.
“The cost is certainly a factor but should not be the lone factor,” he said. “I don’t subscribe to the rosy budget scenario … there’s a point where we have to go with the trust that a newly elected school board under a Freeport-only model will be able to manage the budget.”
The complete withdrawal agreement to be voted on Nov. 4 is available on the Freeport Withdrawal Committee website at www.freeportwc.org. The town’s financial analysis is available at www.freeportmaine.com.
rgargiulo@timesrecord.com
Yes For Freeport vs. Better Together
— YES FOR FREEPORT members cited dropping enrollment numbers, which they speculated is owing to sub-par programming compared to regional, private and charter schools, the so-named “RSU 5 budget wars” over school improvement bonds, and overcrowded classrooms and facilities among reasons they supported withdrawal.
— BETTER TOGETHER members countered by citing diverse programming offered in RSU 5 schools and class sizes that met the state average, the benefits of a larger a student body in terms of sports performance and socialization, and the risk of potential tax increases associated with withdrawal among reasons they supported remaining in the RSU.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less