3 min read

To begin, I think it would be helpful to mention that I am not a member of the NRA, I do not view President Obama as some kind of Stalinist tyrant, and I am not advocating for zero gun control.

But I do support the right of civilians to own semiautomatic military-style rifles, such as AR-15’s (fully automatic weapons are already restricted). I have several reasons for this position.

First, the problem of mass shootings appears to be the main driver of efforts to ban these guns, but many of the worst mass shootings in our country did not involve rifles at all. For example, only handguns were used in the Virginia Tech shooting which claimed even more lives than Newtown. I think it is reasonable to view this as evidence that military-style rifles do not pose a unique threat from mass shooters compared with other guns, so banning these rifles in particular would not have any public benefit.

Second, I believe that in the long run, the most important reason for retaining the right to these weapons is that it is possible that in some future decade or even century, a genuinely totalitarian regime could replace our republic. If that happens, and non-violent efforts prove incapable of protecting the people, then widespread possession of military style rifles would provide the population a minimally sufficient means to fight the military.

Many people dismiss this view as paranoid and radical because the strongest gun rights supporters in the media today are a small group of extreme rightwing propagandists who claim that even healthcare reform is tyranny. But if we consider the reason for bearing arms on its own merits then we can see that the concept is quite valid. Is a totalitarian regime guaranteed to take over one day? No. But there are countless historical precedents of such regimes coming to power or developing from governments that the people originally supported. So the premise isn’t absurd.

Advertisement

Third, proponents of banning these rifles often argue that the government’s military is so powerful and technologically advanced that its tanks, planes, and missiles would clearly wipe out any opposition armed with rifles.

But armed conflict in the real world is not comparable to a video game where two sides face off directly and the one with the greater “power level” automatically wins. A resisting population would adopt guerrilla methods of fighting. This would deny the other side the conditions necessary for their technological superiority to be a major factor. And furthermore, note that resistance forces would include former personnel and defectors from the military itself.

Guerrilla methods of fighting were used to impressive effect by the Viet Cong against the United States; by Fidel Castro and his rebels against Batista; by the Mujahadeen against the Soviet Union; and it has managed to keep Jihadist movements alive in Iraq and Afghanistan throughout a decade of assault from the United States’ exorbitantly expensive arsenal of first class targeting systems, tanks, jets, missiles, and artillery.

So we must acknowledge that the concept behind the second amendment is still relevant, because in the long run these wars can prove more costly and difficult for Goliath than for David. It is of course not guaranteed to succeed in every case, but I would much prefer to have a decent chance than none at all.

There are more details I would need to explain in order to make a complete case though, and I am obviously not advocating that we violently fight our current government since even post-9/11 America is not a dictatorship, as worrying as its current programs are. But hopefully some readers have found my arguments about the concept behind the right to own militarystyle rifles worth considering.

———

Aaron Fogg lives in Topsham.



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.