4 min read

Gary Anderson
Gary Anderson
Word has it that the governor’s race will be run till the final mile without the encumbrance of debates, and then as few as possible. So much for an informed electorate. Last time out, Paul LePage avoided debates at any cost, attending about half, and it cost him nothing. High fives all round, but the cost to Maine voters is still being tallied.

LePage, very astutely, gained entrance to the Blaine House by minimizing the liability of speaking impromptu, on record, in a situation beyond his control. He has continued that M.O. for most of his governorship, yet rarely gets it right. Whenever he speaks, a loose canon careens wildly.

For our governor, silence, broken by proclamation, is golden. Though that hasn’t served anyone well, why fool with something proven to work? LePage, therefore, again refuses to debate, at least at this juncture, and Mike Michaud, apparently, also finds that workable. Partisans can continue arguing who might win the day when the two go, hesitantly, into that political unknown where neither feel comfortable.

Separately, Michaud refuses to debate Eliot Cutler separately. The thinking here is that to do so would be to give undue legitimacy to Cutler’s candidacy. Also, public debate of policy differences might provide too much clarity, undercutting the careful manipulation of sound bites still struggling to differentiate Michaud and Cutler’s differences.

Most politicians understand that the less said, for as long as possible, serves best in a world where every word and gesture can become a betrayal of a campaign’s desired perception. Here we have another sign of a pervasive unease loose in our country. In that way, our politics are indeed representative. Too fearful to act, we would rather continue losing than ever risk the changes necessary for us to win back our collective courage. In a rapidly shifting world, our two-party system has become incapacitated by partisan inertia, preaching rote rhetoric to respective choirs, venturing no further than home base and wondering why we have so much trouble getting to first.

Advertisement

Whatever one might think of his independent challenge, Eliot Cutler is a still credible contender despite his polling stats. He came in an extremely close second, last go around, for Maine’s top leadership position. Anyone seeking that job description should be willing to engage a host of debaters, early and often, rather than welcoming postponements for their tactical gain. What we’ve ended up with is a three way race run on separate tracks, crossing only when conditions are favorable to individual entrants.

Cutler, odd man out, readily favors any and all debate with either of his competition. Ironically, that emphasizes how much less he has to lose in doing so, accentuating his more and more third wheel reality. Shaking things up can only be to his advantage.

In a democracy, leadership is all about taking charge as a representative voice for what should be conserved or what should be changed. Those positions become clear once one is in office, but that may be an awkward time to finally get to know your candidate’s actual agenda.

I thought for sure that Barack Obama was being coy about embracing nuclear power, only to find President Obama actually favoring it. Sometimes, even what they say straight-out is lost in trying to unspin spin.

Cutler has made it clear that he thinks Mainers vote for the person and not the candidate’s ideology. When your temperament is most similar to the candidate furthest from your own ideology, and when your ideology is closest to the candidate least like yourself, that is indeed a curious statement to make, and well worth our careful consideration. LePage is not into conversion of disbelievers, remaining steadfast and entrenched in assuring that his second act will be more of the same, and then some. It is doubtful that there remain very many who are confused about whether LePage should have a second term. That vote has likely been cast. Michaud and Cutler are thereby faced with determining how to capture a lion’s share of the remaining electorate, especially those still undecided.

Having run and lost last time, Cutler remains a persistent business “turnaround” achiever now trying to turn his polling numbers around to where they were four years ago. He is a potential comeback kid going up against a quietly resolute victor who, low keyed and high principled, has never lost an election.

Advertisement

For all three, but especially Michaud, the game is theirs to loose by choosing poorly in how to play out the shortening season. Running out the clock on debates until absentee ballots have been cast is a disappointing gamesmanship and a most cold calculation in winning over those already disenchanted with the sport.

For too many, the passionless brinkmanship of current politics is as off-putting as its major play of endless branding. Name recognition is even less reason for voting than personality. What a candidate means to achieve, and how that achievement will be realized, is what one’s vote should go to.

And, that should be thoroughly and willingly debated.

———

Gary Anderson lives in Bath.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.