4 min read

Gary Anderson
Gary Anderson
Much has been said about the pros and cons of a passenger rail layover facility in Brunswick. I have followed the controversy with interest, in that it has many similarities to my own neighborhood’s struggle over a decade ago.

Then, it was the livability of Bath’s South End pitted against the economic interests of the city, the state of Maine and that of the state’s largest employer. Neighbors of the planned project, supportive of BIW yet concerned over perceived impacts, were soon caught up in a fight where they were castigated as NIMBY obstructionists.

After all, they chose to live next to a historic manufacturing site, and manufacturing often has collateral fallout. Whatever negative impact, their individual concerns were something they should have anticipated, and willingly accept. No one forced them to live there. Buck up, or move.

Some chose not to accept that prevailing rationale. They banded together and opposed what others saw as unavoidable and needed concessions to progress and the greater good. The impacted citizens received no help from local government or the rest of the city. However, their state representatives, most impressively, did join them, and a long process of trying to find common ground and true accommodation started forward. That process was contentious and difficult, but, by slowing down a bureaucracy gamed for others’ vested interests, avenues never considered emerged. Real solutions, rather than some legalistic charade, were eventually found. Instead of one side winning, the other crushed, both sides came out ahead, for the most part.

In the end, it turned out that the NIMBYs didn’t need to be abandoned to their fate. Their fate was renegotiated. Negative impacts that couldn’t be avoided were avoided. Residents actually managed to have a say, and more than just what color the Kennebec eclipsing drydock should be painted. Exactly. The same old same old never gets old.

Advertisement

I love NIMBYs because they are at least honest about their self interest. Those that oppose them, professing only concern for the greater good, might reconsider if that is entirely true. The engine of economic growth is often a devious determinant in deciding who gets on board, and why. ALAISEY ( As Long As It’s Someone Else’s Yard ) is hardly the acronym of good governance or community. The Golden Rule might also be consulted from time to time.

Sidebar: The Army Corps, helpful throughout, as was DEP staff, substantiated that the drydock could be implemented slightly upriver rather than as proposed. Dismissed out of hand by BIW, that had been an argument for avoiding all impact to neighbors. When so informed, the Board of Environmental Protection still ruled to allow the facility as planned. Time was a-wastin’. The train had already left the station.

The return of rail service to the Mid-coast has been slow hard work for all those involved. It is envisioned as bringing an economic boon to many parties, a dream more powerful than its reality thus far. Whether this proposed layover facility is really optimally placed seems secondary to just putting one foot in front of the other in hurrying towards that dream’s end. The tincture of time can be difficult medicine to swallow by those disinterested in someone else’s headache, and now there is growing opposition beyond those stalwart NIMBYs. All the more reason to hasten.

South Portland’s own momentous NIMBY victory, over tar sands’ runaway train loaded with far reaching economic freight, is an incredible example of visionary municipal leadership. Brunswick’s layover facility’s impact may exact a small fare in comparison, but any fare should be fair.

The return of rail service no better realized than it was a generation ago, spewing patently foul pollution presented as a supposed environmental improvement, seems somewhat more backward looking than visionary. The very need for an layover “enclosure” is clearly because such technology of old is still economically and environmentally challenged.

When I am in Portland, and see all the cars parked at Amtrak, I acknowledge rail’s beneficial success. However, when I come out of Hannaford and see museum-ready rail cars looking so forlorn and disheveled, I can’t help but think of California’s BART realization of actually being transported into the future. Then again, if you ever hear the banshee scream of BART approaching or leaving a station, you might abandon all wishes for the advancement of modern rail service.

Advertisement

Life has its trade-offs, but cohabitation can also be far better realized, finding proper accommodation instead of ready divisiveness and dismissal.

Not long ago, CMP succeeded in railroading smart meters into every community. Bath demonstrated truly right governance — “Not In Our City” — but in the end bowed to legal intimidation. That was still a victory for community solidarity.

Like CMP, NNEPRA’s victory seems inevitable, but then so did South Portland’s acceptance of a tar sands terminal.

Consider if South Portland could-might-did become the site of NNEPRA’s layover facility, and Brunswick West was spared all impact, real or imagined, and there was, in hindsight, actually no need to force fit a problem in the first place.

———

Gary Anderson lives in Bath.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.