
High on a hill overlooking the Sheepscot River, the world has changed around the historic mansion known as Castle Tucker — and now Castle Tucker is changing too.
But not too much, promises Historic New England’s Castle Tucker site director Peggy Konitzky, who is overseeing a $500,000 restoration project taking place this summer and throughout next year. Currently the masonry on the north bow end — a rounded bay facing Lee Street, is being restored and repaired by Knox Masonry, of Bucksport, and carpenter Bruce Blanchard is restoring the bay’s windowsills that have rotted.

“In this organization, we try to save as much of the historic fabric as possible,” he added, “but this sill is a very intricate design and I have very little that hasn’t rotted away to work with.”
The house is also slated for repainting, said Konitzky, and the roof over the north end bow will be repaired. The second floor piazza’s two story-high windows will be repaired as will the piazza roof, which Konitzky said started leaking this summer.
Great lengths have been gone to to preserve the historic integrity of the home that was built in 1807 by Judge Silas Lee, said Konitzky. A Harvard graduate, judge and congressman, Lee was appointed District Attorney of Maine by Thomas Jefferson in 1802.
“There are so many things about this house that are unusual,” said Konitzky. “It was designed to be a fashionforward house, we believe.”
She noted that none of Lee’s papers have ever been found.
“No one knows what his inspiration was is designing this house,” Konitzky said.
The central part of the house is in a traditional federalist style, said Konitzky, with bays added which extend from this. The house has approximately 25 rooms, 10 of which are bedrooms, she said, as well as a studio, carriage house, hay barn and barn attached to the house.
“The family also left their carriages and their sleigh,” said Konitzky, “and those are still here.”
The Historic New England property care team commissioned a detailed masonry, mortar and paint analysis last winter, said Konitzky, which pinpointed the paint and mortar used during each era of the house.
Built in a time before safety codes, Konitzky said Tucker Castle has presented many surprises over the course of the restoration work, both owing to the varying quality of craftsmanship put into it, and the fortunes of the families that inhabited it after Lee.
“The person who built the house had the most money to take care of it and everybody since then has not,” said Konitzky. “The Tuckers who bought the house in 1858 were very well off initially, but their fortune dwindled and they were not able to do extensive repairs or maintenance.
“They did what they could,” she said, “but the quality of paint used was poor, and the mortar repairs — at one point they used cement and not mortar, which added to the problem of water getting in and not being able to get out.”
They were also unable to update the house’s furnishings, said Konitzky, which incidentally has made Castle Tucker a virtual time-capsule of a Victorian-era home.
Prior to the Tuckers, the home was purchased by Franklin Clark, who moved the chimney from the center of the house to the side.
“Everyone knew he was a crook — he was a crooked congressman and he wanted everyone in town to think he had money,” said Konitzky, “but he was arrested by the sheriff trying to flee town in the middle of night without paying his debts.
“Knowing what kind of person he was, it’s no wonder his remodeling has been so problematic,” she added.
To repair and restore the Castle Tucker masonry, each brick was numbered before it was removed to assure that bricks could be returned to their original location. Bricks too degraded to be restored are replaced and labeled with the date of installation.
“We try to make any repairs and restorations that we do obvious to anyone after us, so they know what we’ve done and what was there originally,” said Konitzky. To the untrained eye, however, these shifts in masonry and woodwork may easily blend in.
Castle Tucker, located at 2 Lee St., is open for tours May 31 through Oct. 15, from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Sunday. Tours begin every half hour, with the last tour starting at 4 p.m. Tours are $8 for adults, $7 for seniors and $4 for students.
Konitzky will be leading a special hour-and-a-half-long “behind closed doors” tour on Aug. 22 and Sept. 19, which will include an exploration of the third floor and attic of Castle Tucker, which are typically closed to tours. Tickets are $15 for this tour and registration is required. For more information call 882-7169.
Historic New England is a nonprofit heritage organization founded in 1910 to preserve and present the cultural heritage of New England. Historic New England maintains 36 sites, including Castle Tucker and the Nickels- Sortwell House in Wiscasset.
rgargiulo@timesrecord.com
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less