BRUNSWICK
The Federal Railroad Administration released its environmental assessment on plans for an Amtrak Downeaster layover facility in the Brunswick West neighborhood. FRA brought in a finding of no significant impact, clearing the way for the facility to be constructed.
“Our finding is based upon a thorough analysis as required by the National Environmental Protection Act,” wrote Kevin Thompson, associate administrator of FRA, in a statement Tuesday afternoon. “The facility will keep locomotives and train sets inside to avoid idling train engines outside, thus reducing environmental effects. NNEPRA and FRA have actively solicited public feedback about the facility’s potential impacts on the environment.”
The finding is the final determination that concludes the environmental review for the project, according to Thompson.
The facility, as planned and presented by NNEPRA, “will have no foreseeable significant impact on the quality of the human or natural environment,” according to the finding.
Speaking on Tuesday, NNEPRA Executive Director Patricia Quinn said she did not yet have a chance to review the details of the findings. Quinn said NNEPRA will determine the next steps after the authority meets with the FRA and Consigli Construction Co., which is building the facility.
“Obviously, this is the outcome we had hoped for,” said Quinn.
Quinn’s comments were echoed by those of Wayne Davis, chairman of Train- Riders/North East, a passenger rail advocacy group.
“That’s what we thought it should be from the very beginning,” Davis said, regarding the finding. “NNEPRA had done everything requested of them from the FRA. We could never understand why it was questioned.”
“It’s been a long time coming,” Davis added.
Not everyone is pleased by the FRA’s decision. The Brunswick West Neighborhood Coalition has objected to having the mammoth, industrial-like facility in their neighborhood.
“Holy Christmas,” said coalition member Bob Morrison, upon being informed of the FRA’s decision. “That’s a shock. That’s a real shock. I’m extremely, extremely disappointed and upset.”
Morrison said the coalition will appeal.
“We’re certainly not going to give up, and not going to stop fighting for what’s right,” said Morrison. “We’re not well funded, we’re not well staffed, but we’re just not going to stand by and see this uncontested.”
The coalition had pushed for an additional Environmental Impact Statement on the proposal and had gotten support from both state Sen. Stan Gerzofsky and Gov. Paul LePage. However, a divided Brunswick Town Council could not muster enough support in its own ranks to formally request the study from the FRA.
Efforts to reach Gerzofsky and LePage’s office for comment were unsuccessful Tuesday. Town Council Chairman Benet Pols, who was in favor of requesting the study, said on Tuesday that he wanted more time to review the FRA’s findings, consisting of several hundred pages of reports, comments and other documents.
Had the study been done, Morrison said, it might have made a difference in the FRA’s decision.
The facility will be located a half mile west of Brunswick Station, at the site of a former freight rail yard between Church Road and Stanwood Street on land owned by NNEPRA. It will provide overnight storage for three train sets in a building 655 long, 70 feet wide, and 37 feet high.
According to the FRA’s finding, the enclosed facility will allow trains to power down during midday, reducing diesel emissions, vibrations and noise otherwise produced while the trains are idling, all of which has been a cause of complaints for many who are living and working in areas near the tracks.
Thompson said that design measures of the facility have addressed potential adverse effects the facility might have on neighbors.
“NNEPRA has agreed to place lownoise rooftop fans atop of the maintenance facility to reduce noise levels and emissions, as well as employ design standards that will limit noise exposure and utilize lighting fixtures that will diffuse and deflect lighting at night away from the surrounding neighborhood,” Thompson stated.
Construction and operation of the facility won’t approach EPA air quality thresholds, and NNEPRA has promised Downeaster trains will not idle outside the facility, apart from idling associated with moving trains in and out of the facility, according to FRA.
The facility “will not create significant, adverse vibration impacts,” nor will it cause “moderate or severe” issues with noise, according to the FRA.
In response to neighbors’ concerns about security, NNEPRA has volunteered to install fencing on the north side of the facility. NNEPRA will also plant vegetation to attempt to shield the facility from the direct line of site of up to eight nearby residential properties, according to the administration.
At least one resident in the Brunswick West area lauded the FRA’s decision.
“This is a great day for passenger train service in Brunswick,” said Redwood Lane resident Jeff Reynolds, who said that opposition to the project has been “extremely localized” to those who live along the tracks.
“Let’s break ground right now,” said Reynolds. “The sooner we do, the sooner the trains go indoors.”
jswinconeck@timesrecord.com
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less