5 min read

GREGG COHEN, an environmental analyst with Stantec, displayed several maps highlighting the obstructions, marked in red, located both on and off Wiscasset Airport grounds during a meeting Tuesday night.
GREGG COHEN, an environmental analyst with Stantec, displayed several maps highlighting the obstructions, marked in red, located both on and off Wiscasset Airport grounds during a meeting Tuesday night.
WISCASSET

With one member absent from Tuesday night’s meeting, the Wiscasset Board of Selectmen were unable to break a stalemate vote regarding the adoption of the Wiscasset Municipal Airport’s Master Plan.

Selectmen Pam Dunning and Jeff Slack voted in favor of adopting the plan and, in his final meeting on the selectboard, outgoing Chairman Ed Polewarczyk and Vice Chairwoman Judy Colby were opposed. Selectman Tim Merry was absent.

Prior to the regular meeting, a public hearing took place to discuss a draft environmental assessment that analyzed the environmental impact of alternatives for obstruction removal pursuant to objectives stated in the master plan, a document that outlines the developmental goals of the airport for the next 20 years.

Parting out the ramifications of adopting the Airport Master Plan from the implications of the assessment were at the core of the unresolved vote, with some selectmen adopting the perspective that the plan could be amended if necessary at a later date, and others urging caution in endorsing a legal document that could impact a local business.

Advertisement

According to the draft assessment, trees located off airport grounds — most significantly at Chewonki Campground — have grown to protrude into airspace to a height that is deemed unsafe for incoming aircraft per Federal Aviation Administration standards.

“The safety issue associated with this is paramount and so critical,” said Gregg Cohen, an environmental analyst with Stantec Con- sulting Services, the agency contracted to draft the assessment, “that until this issue is resolved, we can’t focus on any other improvement project at the airport.”

Wiscasset Municipal Airport is obligated through grant assurances with the FAA, Cohen said, to clear the obstructions to maintain a safe operational environment.

At the May 31 Town Meeting, the town voted to raise and appropriate $316,657 for airport operations and appropriate the airport’s estimated revenues of $323,415 to reduce the town’s tax commitment. The 2013-14 fiscal year was, according to the updated Airport Master Plan, “the first time in the airport’s history that aviation derived revenue (excluding property taxes) exceeded expenses by about $17,000.”

Cohen cautioned that the ramifications of not removing trees obstructing airspace would mean, “future development and improvement projects couldn’t take place,” and restrictions would be placed on the operations that could be conducted at the airport.

Mitigating these obstructions, according to the draft assessment, could mean either a full clear of 61 acres, 15 of which are located off airport grounds — four at Chewonki Campground — or it could mean a partial clear of 19 acres — two at Chewonki Campground — and a lighting plan to mark the remaining obstructions.

Advertisement

For the full clear option, 13 easements would have to be acquired for obstruction removal, while the partial clear would require three easements be acquired. In either alternative, an easement would have to be acquired for removal of obstructions from Chewonki Campground.

Pam Brackett, the coowner of Chewonki Campground with her sister Ann Beck, said the trees obstructing airspace were planted by their parents who opened the campground in 1961 — the same year the airport opened. They were placed to delineate the space around sites and offer shade to campers.

“I would ask that the mitigation be looked at very restrictively in favor of the landowner,” said Jim Hopkinson, of Hopkinson & Abbondanza, the attorney representing Chewonki Campground. “There are significant impacts to the landowner, who has been a neighbor to the airport for years without any encroachment of either onto the other.”

Hopkinson said there are airports where the approach to one runway may be standard while to another the approach may be non-standard, and requested that some alternatives be studied that would alter the method or angle of approach so as not to so severely affect the campground.

In a letter to the selectboard and airport manager, Brackett listed five alternatives to easement acquisition and obstruction removal as detailed in the draft assessment.

Brackett said the campground has in excess of 10,000 visitors every year, and brings in more than $600,000 in revenues to the town.

Advertisement

“To take the trees on our property, as suggested by the Airport Master plan or (environmental assessment),” said Brackett, “would potentially eliminate 23 of our sites.”

Losing half of the campground’s 47 sites, Brackett said, “it would be really difficult for us to survive as a business.”

“If you were to accept the master plan, a valuable business, run for over 50 years by two local women would be, simply said, destroyed,” she said. “We encourage you to make some amendments to the master plan and perhaps include the alternatives that our attorney has recommended.”

Airport Manager Ervin Deck said, “I’m going to do everything in my power, and (Brackett) has my promise on that, to make sure that any impact that occurs, and I don’t know what they are going to be, will be as minimal as possible.”

Beck asked if it would be possible to add language to the Airport Master Plan to include the runway and approach alternatives discussed by Hopkinson so that they would considered before mitigation action was taken.

“We can discuss it … but it won’t have any impact on the number of trees currently classified as obstructions,” said Deck. “We can put in there that we … considered them, and we rejected them,” he said, as they could not be recommended as viable options.

Advertisement

“I see the need that we have a safe area for the airport — no argument there,” said Polewarczyk. “It’s important to me also that … the campground be made whole — they’re going to be hurt by this one and they have to be made whole by this process.

“That’s not going to be an easy thing to do,” he added.

Polewarczyk recommended that the town attempt to reach an agreement with the owners of Chewonki Campground before the selectboard vote to adopt the Airport Master Plan.

The motion to approve the Airport Master Plan failed, with two votes in favor of its adoption and two opposed.

Interim Town Manager Don Gerrish said the board would take up the approval at a later date when the full five-member board was present for a tie-breaker.

rgargiulo@timesrecord.com


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.