5 min read

WINDHAM – Neighbors and a former colleague of Stephen McKenney, the Windham resident who was fatally shot by a Cumberland County Sheriff’s Office deputy early Saturday morning, say they are shocked and bewildered by the events that suddenly ended the life of the 66-year-old retired bus driver.

Just after 6 a.m. on April 12, officers from the sheriff’s department and the Windham Police Department responded to a complaint of a suicidal individual on 2 Searsport Way, off Provost Drive, just south of North Windham.

Within minutes of the call authorities say, McKenney was dead in the driveway, shot by Nicholas Mangino, a 25-year-old sheriff’s deputy who has been on the job for two years. According to police, McKenney displayed a firearm and was subsequently shot.

According to neighbors Carol and Thomas Ferrante, McKenney’s body lay uncovered in the driveway across from their home throughout most of the morning.

“What I think bothered us the most besides what did happen to him was that he lay in that driveway for many, many hours, and he wasn’t covered,” said Carol Ferrante.

“I don’t know why they didn’t cover him,” said Thomas Ferrante.

Advertisement

The Ferrantes said that McKenney was a tall, “very sociable” man who hated the cold, and often would bike and walk around their quiet cul-de-sac, which is predominantly filled with 2000s-era yellow condominiums that are populated by senior citizens. McKenney was known to go door-to-door saying hello to his neighbors, they said, and frequently discussed his desire to be in either Arizona or Florida.

“I never had a negative thought about the man,” Carol Ferrante said. “Never.”

Thomas Ferrante said that he heard two gunshots go off on Saturday morning, and didn’t think much of the noise, assuming it was fireworks. When he walked outside, he saw McKenney lying in the driveway. A detective from the Windham Police Department interviewed the couple afterward.

“We liked the guy,” said Thomas Ferrante. “Just a friendly guy. I would never have thought this would have ever, ever have happened to him.”

Michael Kelly, the transportation director for Regional School Unit 14, said that McKenney was a bus driver for Windham schools from February 2005 through August 2012.

“He was reliable, dependable, and friendly to everybody,” Kelly said. “There was absolutely no indication whatsoever of any problems.”

Advertisement

“People around here would see him and talk about him periodically, but nobody had anything negative to say at all,” Kelly said. “It was always positive.”

Kelly said he remembered McKenney being “anxious to go down to Arizona at some point.”

Kelly, who was once the chief of the Lewiston Police Department and commissioner of the Maine Department of Public Safety, said that McKenney’s death was “tragic” and “very, very unfortunate.”

“I feel for Steve’s family and I feel for the police officer equally,” Kelly said. “I am a retired police officer after 28 years, so I understand the pressure and I understand the anxiety.”

The Maine attorney general is reviewing the shooting, in accordance with state statute. Tim Feeley, a spokesman for the state attorney general, declined to comment on the matter. Windham Police Chief Rick Lewsen and Sheriff Kevin Joyce, citing the attorney general’s pending investigation, also declined to comment on the case.

“No more comments,” Joyce said. “I’ve been advised by the AG’s office not to comment anymore.”

Advertisement

McKenney’s wife, Vicki, declined to comment, as well. Her attorney, Daniel Lilley, said that she witnessed the incident from the back seat of a Windham police cruiser, after she called 911 to alert them that her husband was expressing suicidal sentiments in response to his chronic back pain.

“He’d had this since September or October of last year,” Lilley said. “He was helping a neighbor move an air conditioning system out of the house, and he wrenched his back in some fashion and he was being treated for it, and not effectively. He was having more and more pain and the painkillers that he was being prescribed were not alleviating the pain and it was becoming a very difficult issue for him.

“She called the police because he was having such pain that he was saying things like he couldn’t stand this anymore, and she felt that he was so distraught that he could harm himself,” Lilley said.

According to Lilley, Vicki McKenney said that her husband, a veteran, walked out of their garage holding a .357 Magnum handgun that he kept in their bedroom.

Lilley said that McKenney had her eyes “riveted” on her husband throughout the duration of the episode.

“She was in the back seat,” Lilley said. “The officer was in the driver’s seat. She was behind the passenger’s seat watching her husband. There was nobody in front of her. Her husband’s hands, she said, were down. She’s absolutely certain that his hands were by his side and then he was shot and fell to the ground, as the hands never left his sides. She was about 75 yards away, she estimates.”

Advertisement

According to Lilley, Vicki McKenney watched her husband walk out of the garage holding the handgun. Stephen McKenney was standing still when he was shot, according to Lilley.

“The first things she saw in terms of shooting, she saw the ground lift up, indicating to her that a bullet hit the ground,” Lilley said. “The second bullet she didn’t see, but her husband dropped to the ground. She didn’t see either bullet.”

According to Lilley, McKenney did not hear the police officers talking or yelling at her husband.

“She didn’t hear anything being said to him,” he said. “I don’t know whether windows were up or down. But she didn’t hear any conversations throughout the entirety of when she was in the car looking at her husband walking down the driveway.”

Lilley said that Vicki McKenney’s testimony suggests that Mangino may have broken state law, which allows officers to use deadly force if they or someone else are in imminent danger or for several other reasons.

“Given her evidence, it would indicate that they were not justified,” he said.

According to protocol for officer-involved shootings, Mangino has been placed on paid administrative leave pending the investigation.

Just after 6 a.m. on Saturday, officers from the Cumberland County Sheriff’s Office and the Windham Police Department responded to a complaint of a suicidal individual at the home, shown here, at 2 Searsport Way in Quartz Circle, which is located just south of North Windham. Within minutes of the call, Stephen McKenney, a 66-year-old Windham resident, was shot dead in the driveway.  

Comments are no longer available on this story