5 min read

SCARBOROUGH – Even before the Scarborough Town Council had leash law recommendations in hand from its new ad hoc Animal Control Advisory Committee – in fact, even before Town Manager Tom Hall finished drafting the group’s final report – dog owners in town began to howl over what’s to come.

The committee proposal was completed by Hall on Feb. 14 and debated by the council at a Feb. 19 workshop, before formal consideration at its regular meeting that night. Both Feb. 19 sessions occurred after the deadline for this week’s print edition of the Current.

If adopted as written, the proposal would ban dogs from running free on municipal beaches during the nesting season for the piping plover, and would add new restrictions during off-season months. However, it also would give dog owners a chance to walk their dogs off leash during early morning hours after July 15, on beaches where no plovers were spotted, or 40 days after the last chick hatched.

But at a Feb. 12 Town Council meeting, some found fault with the new rules, as well as the process that led to their creation.

“First and foremost, there can be no doubt that the committee was set up to deliver a preordained outcome,” said Holmes Road resident Liam Somers, who complained that the committee consisted of just three members from the advocacy group Dog Owners of Greater Scarborough, along with three plover promoters and Councilor Bill Donovan.

“This committee was stacked toward a very specific agenda,” said Somers. “The reality is this was never intended to be a fair and objective process.”

Advertisement

Because Donovan is thought to side with the plover half of the committee –there were many 4-3 split votes during the nine committee meetings leading up to the final recommendation – Somers said the majority of Scarborough voters, who overturned a town-wide leash law in December with 73 percent of the tally, were essentially disenfranchised by the committee roster.

“The majority are forced to fight a battle from an untenable position,” said Somers. “This charade is not going to fly with the pubic.”

Meanwhile, King Street resident Robert Rovner called on Donovan to recuse himself from voting on the committee report at the Feb. 19 council meeting.

Part of that report recommends, as a long-term goal, the creation of dog parks on public property in town, to give dog owners a place other than municipal beaches to run their animals when the plovers are in town. However, Ocean Wood Drive resident Martin Tripp said that, too, was a bad idea. Quickly calculating the cost of a $100,000 dog park to $5 per taxpayer, Tripp called even that nominal cost unreasonable.

“I don’t have a dog,” said Tripp. “I don’t feel I should spend $5 on a dog park, or my wife, or anyone else who doesn’t have a dog. Make the dog owners pay for it.”

Meanwhile, while some residents spoke out in advance of the final report, others tried to intercede in writing.

Advertisement

In a Feb. 12 letter sent to the council, Pillsbury Street resident Joanne Mahoney introduced a “Citizens’ Dog Ordinance proposal” and asked that the councilors consider it at the Feb. 19 meeting as an alternative to the committee report.

Mahoney’s proposal would leave the existing leash law largely untouched, with just a few minor modifications, primarily in the splitting of the summer season into two parts. From June 15 to Labor Day, the current rules would be in effect, except for the extension of the “no dogs” portion of the day by an hour, to 6 p.m., “in consideration for those that do not want to encounter dogs.” Currently, from June 15 to Sept. 15, dogs can be off leash on municipal beaches from sunrise to 9 a.m., are banned from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., and can appear only on a leash from 5 p.m. until sunset.

Mahoney’s plan also adds restrictions not currently in place, from the April 1 start of the plover-nesting season, as cited by U.S. Fish and Wildlife, to June 14. Her proposal allows dogs off leash, if under “voice control,” from sunrise to 9 a.m. and 2 p.m. until sunset, with no dogs allowed between 9 a.m. and 2 p.m. Currently, there are no restrictions during this two-and-a-half-month period, believed to be among the most sensitive for rebuilding plover populations.

“In delivering this proposal, we speak not only for the voters who voted for the referendum,” wrote Mahoney, referring to the Dec. 3 vote to overturn a year-round, town-wide leash requirement, adopted by the council Oct. 2, “but also for those taxpayers who are not able to vote, for those who visit our beaches from ‘away,’ for those coming from surrounding communities, for those who live locally, and for those who have felt the democratic process has not been honored.

“We understand that some change is necessary to better protect the plover, but we feel that if the new ordinance becomes too confusing or restrictive, it will again impact both compliance and enforcement,” wrote Mahoney.

Councilor Jessica Holbrook, who introduced Mahoney’s letter into the public record during the Feb. 12 meeting, said she could support discussing it during the Feb. 19 workshop, but that she was against adding it to the regular meeting agenda.

Advertisement

Council Chairman Richard Sullivan agreed, saying to introduce the proposal as a competing measure would “undermine the committee process.” However, he said it “will definitely be [considered] at workshop.”

Then, on Monday, Feb. 17, councilors received an eight-page memo from Mast Street resident Julie Hannon. Calling the town’s seven-month set-to on leashing requirements “a travesty,” Hannon called on councilors to finally push back against state and federal wildlife officials.

“It is clear that no due diligence was exercised. You did not review and challenge data or reports, and you did not hold the USFW [U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service] accountable to the laws that guide their actions,” wrote Hannon.

Noting landmark case law, which found that beachfront property owners own all the way to the low-water line while the public has rights to “fishing, fowling and navigation in the intertidal area between the mean low- and high-water marks, Hannon concluded that the rights of those private property owners is violated by the committee recommendation.

“If the activities of select private property owners are restricted, beyond that of property owners town-wide, select property owners are not receiving equal protection under the Constitution,” said Hannon, likening the proposed ordinance change to an eminent domain taking without compensation. “If other plover risk factors, such as golfers, recreational sunbathers, kite flyers, fireworks shooters, wind surfers and horse riders are allowed to occupy shoreline near to where plovers are nesting, then dog owners and property owners are not receiving equal protection under the Constitution.”

Hannon also cited several passages of federal law which should have allowed property owners to participate in the town’s negotiations with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, to get compensation for action by a federal agency limiting their property rights, and to inspect all relevant documents.

Comments are no longer available on this story