3 min read

Gary W. Fogg
Gary W. Fogg
The political right in the United States today consists of a coalition of interests that do not always agree on fundamental principles. Nonetheless, the coalition has held together in spite of this for nearly 30 years, perhaps out of sheer desperation. In the process, the Republican Party has become narrower in its views and more ideological in its rhetoric than at any time in its past.

Under the banner of the tea party movement, the Republican Party has become, in essence, a party of revolutionaries. The political rhetoric of the tea party conjures up a mythical past, when Americans were more independent of government and supposedly more heroic in character than now.

The claims of the tea party in respect to the benefits of smaller government do not for the most part stand up to historical scrutiny, but then neither do the beliefs of most political parties. Like religion, politics is not about evidence. Rather, it is a method of standing with others who share our beliefs about the meaning of life.

Whenever we find a group of people in history becoming more shrill in rhetoric and belief over time, we must look to the sources of their fear. Like the white Southerners before the Civil War, conservatives today are fearful of their loss of power in a rapidly changing society.

What factors in America and the world today are causing white, conservative Americans to fear their loss of power? We can summarize the threats in the following manner.

Advertisement

American economic power in relative terms has declined since 1970, due to the increasing prosperity of other nations around the globe.

Key sectors of the U.S. economy, such as manufacturing, have weakened due to global competition.

Minorities in the United States have made economic and social progress since 1970, while immigration has remained strong.

The culture of the United States is becoming more tolerant of non-Christian religions and moral beliefs, including a broadening of ideas about marriage, sexuality and family life.

Advances in scientific knowledge continue to challenge the religious and political beliefs of conservatives. Now, in addition to evolution, cloning and a woman’s ability to control reproduction, there is man’s responsibility for global climate change.

The United States continues to play the biggest role in defending the Western democracies from extremism and authoritarian rule, but at great cost to the nation.

Advertisement

Americans are living longer, but the social programs supporting them were designed for people with much shorter life spans. Thus, the proportion of the federal budget devoted solely to funding social programs has steadily increased over time.

If Americans who believe in progressive policies could develop intelligent and humane responses to these challenges that are such a source of fear to the political right, the power of the tea party movement over the Republican Party might be broken. It would require that the political center and left regain control of the rhetoric on political debate.

Make no mistake, controlling the way issues are framed in a debate is more than half the battle in politics.

In the past, Americans have shown that they can overcome their own limitations by strengthening their best qualities and abandoning whatever is cruel or false. The country faces another challenge today in the form of a new type of extremism that is dividing the nation.

The solution lies in reclaiming the terms of political debate and advancing policies that once again do the greatest good for the greatest number of our fellow citizens.

GARY FOGG is a retired land-use planner and a student of American history. He has lived in Topsham for 23 years.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.