BATH
The City Council voted Wednesday to reject a tax increment financing proposal from Bath Iron Works, opting instead to offer the defense contractor a package yielding a smaller cut of new taxes generated by future development at the shipyard.
After a lengthy public hearing, the council voted 7-1 to approve a TIF that would split new tax revenue stemming from an approved outfitting hall, to be built adjacent to the Ultra Hall, 50-50 for the first 10 years, then 40 percent for BIW for the next five years. After that, Bath would retain 100 percent of the tax revenue from the new building.
BIW had proposed an even, 50-50 split over the full life of the 25-year TIF. Under that plan, BIW stood to get some $250,000 in taxes rebated annually from the city, for a total of about $6.5 million over the life of the TIF. The deal approved Wednesday gives total projected earnings for Bath of $9,014,760 — 71 percent — versus $3,711,960 for BIW — 29 percent.
Jim DeMartini, BIW spokesman, said that BIW was pleased. “We are really happy that the council was patient, and considered all the options for this agreement,” he said. “We’re happy that they approved the amended TIF, and we are looking forward to going ahead with the program, after we dot all the i’s and cross all the t’s.”
Wide disagreement was apparent among Bath citizens attending a public hearing prior to the vote.
Halcyon Blake, who owns a home and business on School Street, said she did not favor the tax break.
“I hope that you (the City Council) understand how the tax cuts to BIW affect the city,” she said. “I hope that BIW has been transparent with you about their need for this tax cut.”
Carol Huntington, a Bowery Street resident who described herself as on a fixed income and caring for a disabled spouse, said she believes tax breaks such as those offered BIW have caused her property taxes to go up.
“ Since 2002, my taxes have gone up from $2,300 per year to $4,000 per year,” she said.
Some favored the TIF. Bill Lent of York Street mused that, “If I were a company with a 5,000 payroll, I’m not sure I’d consider Bath.”
Several people who worked for BIW testified in favor of the TIF.
After the public hearing ended, councilors took up the issue.
Ward 5 Councilor Mari Eosco made the motion to amend the TIF amendment agreement from the 50-50 split over 25 years to 50-50 over 10 years, then a split of 40 percent for BIW and 60 percent for Bath for the next five years, followed by 100 percent for the city for the remainder of the TIF. At large Councilor Steve Brackett seconded it.
Eosco said the city and the corporation were in a symbiotic relationship.
“ I’ve heard everything people have been saying,” she said. “ I take it all to heart. I think we have to find some middle ground.”
Councilor Meadow Merrill, Ward 1, said she favored supporting BIW because of all the support she hears about the TIF in her district, which is in the south end of the city.
Brackett said he believed the compromise TIF agreement was “moving in the right direction” — a sentiment echoed by Councilors David Sinclair, Ward 6; Andy Winglass, at large; Leverett “Tink” Mitchell, Ward 7; Chairman Bernard Wyman, Ward 4; and Sean Paulhus, Ward 2.
Councilor Carolyn Lockwood, Ward 3, said she supported the TIF and would have liked it to yield more benefits to BIW than the compromise offer.
Sinclair offered two amendments to the TIF.
The first amendment tied payment of the BIW rebate portion to consistent employment at the shipyard. The second would have ended the BIW portion after 10 years. Both failed.
Sinclair cast the lone vote against the compromise TIF. Wyman did not vote, as is customary for the chairman except to break a tie.
Jerry Provencher, a member of Bath Citizens for Responsible TIF Action which opposed the initial tax break proposal, praised Wednesday’s vote as a “good example of democracy in action” and said he was “pleased with the way the whole thing went.”
“ Overall I was pleased with the having the people get involved to a larger extent than maybe they would have, and to have had a dialogue with the city” about the proposals, Provencher said.
“Because of the interaction of the people in the city, if BIW goes with this deal, we saved taxpayers $3 million over the course of this TIF deal, and I feel pretty good about that,” he said.
The TIF vote comes as U. S. Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel is due to visit the shipyard this afternoon. Hagel will tour the newest destroyer, the DDG-1000, the first of the Navy’s Zumwalt class of guided missile destroyers, then address an audience of its prospective crew members and members of BIW’s work force.
In other business Wednesday, the City Council also approved budgets for the existing TIF districts for fiscal year 2014.
Also approved were statemandated changes to the minimum and maximum General Assistance values.
The maximum for overall General Assistance funding increased slightly but food assistance — which is tied to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, sometimes known as food stamps — decreased since the food stamp allotment also decreased this year.
ghamilton@timesrecord.com
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less