It’s good to see large organizations work together when there’s a high-profile controversy with lots at stake.
Such has been the process of negotiating new tax breaks for Bath Iron Works. Roundly criticized for seeking public money at a time it is cutting jobs, the shipyard owned by General Dynamics has been working with city officials to amend its initial proposal to somet hing slightly more palatable to Bath’s elected officials and staff, who sit in the crossf i r e between shipyard and city.
The
TIF, as originally proposed, would give the city and BIW a 50-50 split for all new taxes garnered by the construction of a new outfitting hall. BIW would get back some $250,000 in taxes annually, for a total of about $6.5 million over the life of the TIF.
As reported Tuesday at www.timesrecord.com, the city now proposes a 50- 50 split only for 10 years, followed by 40 percent for BIW over the next five years. The remaining term would grant the city 100 percent of new taxes.
According to figures provided by the city, total projected earnings for Bath over the 24-year life of that TIF would be $9,014,760 — 71 percent of the total. BIW would receive $3,711,960 — 29 percent.
For the city, that seems like a more equitable cut — and $9 million in revenue it does not have today. But, ultimately, the City Council is charged with deciding what level of taxation they’re comfortable losing — and for what gain. And that decision is still due tonight.
No one believes BIW’s threat to pull up anchor is all that credible, yet who wants to risk it? And, besides, neighbors help neighbors. In Bath, BIW is everyone’s neighbor.
Bath undoubtedly wants to help win any project that helps create new construction jobs and the ability to anticipate future growth. The question is how expensive it should be to secure that growth.
We’ve come out previously against the TIF as originally proposed, saying in this space on Aug. 16 that, “if you balance the need for a class of overpriced submarines against a variety of pressing local needs, we’d take the money and re-do the viaduct area, open new areas for public recreation, refurbish or relocate Morse High School and a host of other local projects that could put local people to work.”
Given the spirit of negotiation, we’re not as dead set against the TIF as we were (though it is still worth noting the CEO of General Dynamics makes more per year than the entire city of Bath — raising the ever-present question of how urgently the shipyard really needs the money).
We also said, on Sept. 5, that tax-supported development is good when it’s done right. “When it’s done wrong, monopoly interests with connections in high places get free cash, supply meager jobs at poor wages and put taxpayers on the hook for their own private gain should the investment go sour.” Those concerns remain valid.
Perhaps the best thing would be for the residents of Bath to weigh in on the matter in a citywide referendum after the City Council casts its votes tonight.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less