4 min read

Dugan Shipway
Dugan Shipway
As a former president of Bath Iron Works and a resident of Maine and the city of Bath, I have followed the discussions, commentaries and letters to the editor regarding the upcoming tax increment financing decision in front of the Bath City Council. I offer the following thoughts.

The Bath City Council is deliberating a change to the Wing Farm/Enterprise Municipal Development Tax Increment Financing District, which was created by the city of Bath for its own benefit in 2008.

The change being requested is related to a project BIW now proposes to build within that district.

In understanding what this means to the city of Bath, its residents, BIW employees and the state of Maine, it is useful to consider the principles that underpin the Maine statute that permits these types of districts to be established.

The Maine TIF statute was signed into law in the 1990s to stimulate private sector investment and job creation. Its basic purpose is to allow the development of programs, approved at the municipal level, to provide impetus for industrial-commercial development to increase employment. It also allows capturing the value of business capital improvements to fund local economic development. Once a TIF district gains municipal support, the state Department of Economic and Community Development provides final approval.

Advertisement

TIFs are not new to the partnership between BIW and Bath.

In the 1990s, BIW needed to make a $300 million investment for long-term survival and to win competitions with a boat builder in Mississippi. At that time, two BIW TIF districts were established to allow the company to invest in the revolutionary Land Level Transfer Facility, and to renovate its existing facility. New taxes collected partially rebated to BIW enabled this multi-hundred million dollar investment, and then annually provided revenue to the city for needed infrastructure and economic development improvements. It was directly a result of this partnership that BIW won the majority of shipbuilding competitions over the next decade.

From 1998 through the delivery of the DDG 112 last year, 13 ships were built using the new land level facility. These TIFs allowed BIW to build several more DDGs than in Mississippi.

Without this investment, I estimate that possibly 1,000 fewer people would have worked in Bath several of the last 10 years. When you win fewer contracts, you build fewer ships. It is that simple.

The Bath-BIW partnership benefited Bath, the citizens of Maine who kept good-paying jobs, and our shipyard, which steadily improved.

In 2008, during my last year as president, the Wing Farm TIF was approved to capture increased taxes BIW was paying on a new enclosed building area: Ultra Hall. The dramaticallyimproved productivity of BIW’s workers from 2000 through 2007 made this a viable investment for BIW without any economic incentive.

Advertisement

The Wing Farm TIF was a wise move by the city, and further strengthened the Bath-BIW partnership, as it provided economic development funds as well as money to finance downtown improvements for Bath.

What is good for Bath is good for our workers, their families and, thus, for BIW.

Much has changed in the past five years. The Mississippi shipyard has improved its performance building DDGs. Their support at the state and local level has flourished with low-interest loans, state bonds enabling shipyard enhancements, tax exemptions and even a state-funded training facility.

Another huge change is the U.S. Navy has felt ever-increasing budget pressures and sequestration impacts. They are buying fewer ships, and all programs are being competed. Cost is the only criteria for ship awards.

BIW knows what must be done to remain competitive. The company went from launching ships down the ways to horizontally from the Land Level Transfer Facility, and from erecting modules weighing 400 tons to now nearly 4,000 tons.

Today’s challenge: expand the facility to allow total completion of modules within an enclosed building, an Outfitting Hall.

Advertisement

This investment over the next two years would allow BIW to open the competitive advantage needed to continue good-paying jobs for the men and women of Maine.

BIW must again work on a winwin partnership with the city to allow a TIF-supported investment that will make the needed improvements more economically viable, increase the probability of continuing good-paying jobs, and will provide increased tax revenues for desired City Council improvements for Bath.

The partnership between BIW and the City of Ships has been strong for decades. The TIF District proposal before the City Council, if approved, can only strengthen it. I support this partnership between my city and my former employer.

DUGAN SHIPWAY is a retired U.S. Navy admiral, was president of Bath Iron Works for six years and has been a year-round Bath resident for more than a decade.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.