
Even-numbered years are “short” sessions under the state constitution, lasting only till April, rather than June, and legislation is supposed to be of an “emergency” nature. Also, under legislative rules, proposals aren’t supposed to be reruns of bills rejected in the previous session.
The two requirements produced an interesting set-to between majority Democrats, who have six votes, and minority Republicans, who have four.
A top priority for Democrats and House Speaker Mark Eves was another go at the Medicaid expansion Gov. Paul LePage blocked last year. For Republicans, House Minority Leader Ken Fredette was pushing three “welfare reform” measures.
To no one’s surprise, Eves and his colleagues prevailed with Medicaid, also voting down Fredette’s proposals, which had him crying foul.
Fredette contends the Medicaid bill mimics the defeated one, while the alleged “duplication” of his bill to create a work requirement for TANF assistance was only in the eye of the beholder.
But that’s how it works. The constitution doesn’t define “emergency,” so in effect six members of the Legislative Council decide — much the same way five members of the U.S. Supreme Court determine what the U.S. Constitution means. The same goes for “duplicative.” In a program as large and varied as Medicaid, it’s easy to craft a “new” bill.
But is Fredette right even on the merits, rather than the politics?
It’s hard to see what “emergency” is involved in the work search bill. Yes, TANF applications have risen over the last five years, but that’s because the economy for working people nosedived in 2008 and has yet to recover.
Work search requirements are appropriate for unemployment benefits, but what do they have to do with TANF, the federal-state program for those who suddenly experience severe hardship? Typically, they’ve lost a job, a spouse or partner, have suffered domestic abuse, lost their car, their home or apartment, and have nowhere to turn.
This is probably not the best time to require a search for a job they might not be able to accept, given that TANF recipients also care for one or more children. And, even if the requirement were law, it’s a safe bet our shortstaffed state workforce wouldn’t have time to check compliance.
It’s also doubtful Fredette’s bill in any way represents “reform.” Historically, reform meant social and political improvement by legal means, rather than revolution, As political revolution faded, “reform” came to mean improving programs by making them simpler and more efficient — as in the historic and singular federal tax reform of 1986.
As used by Fredette and contemporary Republicans, “reform” means something quite different — dismantling government programs or removing the means to pay for them.
Thus “pension reform” in 2011, when Republicans were fully in charge, meant slashing benefits for current and future state retirees by $1.7 billion. “Tax reform” meant cutting taxes paid disproportionately by the wealthy, the estate and income tax. And now “welfare reform” means making it more difficult for the worst-off among us to receive benefits required by federal law.
In all, Republicans would do well to jettison the “reform” label and replace it with something more honest.
And it’s not as if Fredette doesn’t have options. If LePage likes his bills, he’s free to introduce them himself. Governors can submit whatever legislation they like, at any point of the session, and get a hearing.
Now, as to Medicaid — is accepting health care for 70,000 people paid for by federal funds a true “emergency”? That’s perhaps a close call. The Legislature fell two votes short of overriding LePage’s veto, but votes are usually final even if they’re close.
Yet there’s another element. In 2012, Republicans forced through a supplemental budget by majority vote, rather than the traditional two-thirds, cutting off Medicaid funding for 25,000 Mainers. Come January, we will not only not be adding people to the health care rolls, but subtracting some 2 percent of the state’s population.
Democrats believe Republicans reneged on a 2011 budget deal, after they added their votes to a $500 million tax cut in exchange for promises of no further cuts to programs like Medicaid.
However you view that maneuver — and majority budgets usually come back to haunt the perpetrators — cutting health care for thousands at a time we’re trying to realize a national commitment to offering health care to everyone does constitute an emergency. Let the debate begin.
DOUGLAS ROOKS is a former daily and weekly newspaper editor who has covered the State House for 29 years. He can be reached at drooks@tds.net.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less