3 min read

John Richardson
John Richardson
Last winter, during an ice storm, I rolled my old Chevy S-10 pickup. Luckily, I walked away, but the truck was a mess.

My wife, who’s a doctor, made sure that I was all right, and then, as a joke, put a Band-Aid on the bumper. The idea was that the Band-Aid would fix everything that was wrong with the truck. Of course, it didn’t work.

That’s what I think governor LePage is trying to do with the hospital debt. He has put a Band-Aid on the problem. But he has done absolutely nothing about the underlying cause of the debt, and, by refusing to expand Medicaid, he has undoubtedly made the problem worse.

The hospitals are in trouble for a few reasons. First, there are too many hospital beds in Maine, and they are in the wrong places. Data from the American Hospital Association shows that Maine’s average occupancy rate for hospital beds is well below the national average of 66 percent, and more than half of Maine’s hospitals, all in rural Maine, have occupancy rates below 50 percent.

Like our schools, our hospital capacity is not where our population is.

Advertisement

And, the hospitals, like so many other parts of the health care system, have a broken and unsustainable business model. Even with the repayment of the hospital debt, we have seen a series of recent reports of financial losses among our hospitals. The hospital in Farmington just reported a $8.3 million operating loss.

Maine Medical Center is facing a $13.4 million shortfall and Maine General’s 2013 revenues were down $5 million from its projections, causing Moody’s to downgrade its bond rating. Observers suggest that the hospital business model needs to be changed and that hospitals cannot be all things to all patients.

However, to effect this change, it’s going to take universal insurance and healthcare reform to move in the right direction, and like it or not, that’s going to begin with the president’s health care plan.

But the primary reason for the hospital debt is simply that many Mainers don’t have insurance or the money to go to the doctor — and so they go to the emergency room at their local hospital.

This includes approximately 155,000 people, including the more than 16,300 Mainers ages 50 to 64 that have lost their jobs or are working in jobs without health benefits and 14,500 who are parents. And many have chronic medical conditions that get worse when preventative and regular care is not available.

Right now, the hospitals have to take them in and take care of them, and try to get reimbursed later.

Advertisement

As a rule, Maine hospitals spend around 55 to 60 percent of their time serving people who are eligible for Medicare and Medicaid, but get reimbursed for only 45 to 50 percent.

So as long as Maine is not accepting full federal Medicaid reimbursements, Maine hospitals will be running in the red.

So, hooray. We paid off the debt. But like a patron at a bar, paying off the bar tab doesn’t guarantee that a new tab won’t get started right away.

Since the governor has denied medical care to so many Mainers, even more folks will be using the hospitals as a source of routine health care, or won’t be going to the hospital until things are really, really bad.

And the debt will start to grow again.

So, governor, we’re still waiting for a comprehensive health care plan from you. It’s time for you to be for something, instead of continuing to be the person who just says no.

JOHN RICHARDSON, an at-large member of the Brunswick Town Council, is an attorney with Moncure & Barnicle in Topsham.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.