2 min read

A CLAMMER rinses his haul of clams at Simpson’s Point boat landing Aug. 2.
A CLAMMER rinses his haul of clams at Simpson’s Point boat landing Aug. 2.
Restoration of power boat access at Simpson’s Point in Brunswick is a solution in search of a problem.

As it stands now, no power boats are allowed there. They can use the Mere Point boat landing not more than a couple miles down the road and only a few hundred feet of shoreline away, as the crow flies.

The reason for the moratorium, ostensibly, is that eelgrass, which might have been damaged by power boats, may not have recovered during the moratorium.

So, to review: Rules were enacted to stop something that no one knows was a problem, and now no one knows whether the new rules worked or not.

Fair enough. But the issue of competing waterfront access is an old saw in Maine, and regardless of the particulars in this case — it seems like the same old “traditional vs. contemporary” battle to us — we see a very easy solution, and it hinges on appropriate use.

Advertisement

Is it appropriate for the owners of power boats to insist on using Simpson’s Point when they have better alternative launch locations so close by?

The cul-de-sac that passes for a parking lot at Simpson’s Point hardly accommodates a boat trailer backing down the ramp as it is — at least without endangering pedestrians, who also enjoy the site for its vistas and rocky beachfront. On the other hand, Mere Point has a wider apron and a newer ramp for boaters that doesn’t particularly appeal to public bathers or other users.

Clammers, meanwhile, like the mucky bottom and wide tidal flats at Simpson’s Point, and couldn’t find a suitable replacement for these beds over at Mere Point if power boats came back.

Eelgrass or no eelgrass, it seems to us that keeping things the way they are now — with Simpson’s Point off limits to power boats — behooves clammers, conservationists, casual users of Simpson’s Point and power boaters, too.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.