5 min read

– FOR THE AWARD WINNING RECIPE, SEE TOMORROW’S PRINT EDITIONS OF THE TIMES RECORD –

Tyrrell Hunter, of Brunswick, is a repeat winner of the seafood cookoff at the annual Rockland Lobster Festival. ROSANNA GARGIULO / Fpr The Times RecordBRUNSWICK

The day after the competition, Tyrrell Hunter is still not ready to rest.

Advertisement

In her kitchen, the Saturday afternoon light glows in the steam rising from a pot on her range top. It reflects off the marble island where Hunter prepares a “simple” lobster chowder.

Her seafood cannelloni blew away the judges who this weekend named her, for the second year in a row, the winner of the 2013 Maine Seafood Cooking contest at the Maine Lobster Festival.

“I wasn’t going to compete,” Hunter said Saturday. “I won last year, so there’s a psychological piece to it; I figured I should give someone else a chance.

“I was lying in bed and the competitor in me thought, ‘Hypothetically, if I was going to compete, what would I do?’ The first lesson I learned was to feature lobster prominently.”

Hunter, a Brunswick resident with a professional background in marketing and interior decorating, said she draws on these skills to conceptualize and execute her award-winning dishes.

“The idea is really like a marketing stratagem,” she says.

Advertisement

To compete, home cooks submit recipes that are then reviewed by a panel. The panel selects the five most promising recipes and invites the submitters to Rockland to join a live cook-off.
“The first year I competed, I made salmon with a lobster mousse,” Hunter says. “I didn’t win that year, but one of the judges pulled me aside and told me my flavors were the best but that one of the judges hadn’t liked that the star of the dish was salmon.”

Hunter shrugged: “It’s a seafood cooking contest, technically. But I learned a lesson there: Lobster wins.”

Over the last three years, she said the winning dishes have all featured lobster and scallops.

“Obviously things need to taste good,” she adds, “And I taste things acutely. People’s tastebuds vary like voices vary. I smell acutely, too. When I cook, I can smell when a cake is done. It’s really about using all your senses.”

Of her prize-wininng cannelloni, she says: “It’s not for every day. It’s rich, it’s — well, I don’t want to say caloric, but it is — very caloric.”

“Then I wondered, ‘How do I feature lobster in a cannelloni?’” Hunter says, “First I decided I wouldn’t add any spinach; that would overwhelm the flavor.”

Advertisement

Then inspiration struck.

“The béchamel. I’d bump it up with lobster and anchovies and use that to soften up the filling a touch.”

Once the dish was conceptualized, Hunter says, “I roughed it out. The first time I made it I cooked the lobster the day before. The second time I made a trial dish, I did it all in the same day.”

She says, “The second time, it wasn’t as good. There was too much moisture in the dish and I lost some of the lobster flavor. For the competition I made darn sure that I prepared the lobster the day before.”

“The day of the competition is crazy,” she says. “You have to get there by 8:30 in the morning to unload at the site.” The set up was the greatest challenge for Hunter. “There are five cooks, four tables, and three ovens. It’s a friendly competition, but I marked my space out with tote bags. Last year I was getting squeezed off the table.”

Competitors have two and a half hours to prepare their dish. In this time they also have to lay a table they’ve designed and present the dish paired with a beverage of their choosing. 
“I thought I was so organized,” Hunter says, “but I forgot a measuring cup and a cutting board. Once you start cooking, you can receive no assistance.”

Advertisement

“You can have someone else decorate the table for you,” she says, “But I did it myself. Some people do massive tablescapes, but I think the table shouldn’t overwhelm the dish. It’s the dish that wins.” Of this year’s five competitors, Hunter was the only female. She says, “It’s funny, in previous years people weren’t accessorizing their plates as much. Now they’re focusing more on accompaniment.”

For Hunter, picking a winning dish is like decorating: “You start with one thing and build around it.” Hunter usually plates on white dishes, to “make the food pop” but, she says, “With the pasta, béchamel, and lobster, the food is all practically white itself.” This year she chose navy blue plates to make her dish stand out.

“To pair with the cannelloni, I made a salad of edible flowers and a light vinaigrette. I specifically chose the salad to pick up the navy and gold color scheme I had worked out.” For her beverage, she chose Prosecco; “As I said, it’s a special occasion dish.”

Hunter first got the idea to cook competitively when she saw an article in the newspaper about the Maine Lobster Festival in July of 2011. It was a difficult summer for Hunter; after 15 years as owners and operators of a medical supply business, Hunter and her husband had just been forced to close their doors.

“We’d been very successful with Majors Mobility, we even opened a branch store in Scarborough,” she says. “Soon thereafter Medicare made some drastic cuts. They slashed reimbursements by 30% and changed the reimbursement process, increasing the paperwork. It made it harder for people the access, and it was a lot more work for us,” she says.

Hunter was concerned with more than just her own well-being though, “In a small business, everyone is like family. It’s awful to have to let people go when you know they are depending on you. It really hurt. Cooking was a comfort to me then,” Hunter says, “It was cook or cry.”

Rosanna Gargiulo is a correspondent for The Times Record. She lives in Brunswick.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.