
The answer was unequivocal.
“I’m not answering any questions about this sale,” City Council Chairman Bernie Wyman said Wednesday at a special workshop.
His colleagues then followed suit.
The workshop — filled to overflowing — was scheduled primarily to answer citizens’ questions about the city’s April 17 sale of the former Bath Hospital building at 9 Park St.
The building, bought for $1 in 2002 from Mid Coast Hospital was sold for $799,000 to Robert Smith, owner of Kennebec Landing and a member of the Phippsburg Planning Board. Details of the deal were revealed to councilors in executive session, without public input or hearings.
The council unanimously approved the sale. But questions about the timing of events, whether or not the building was listed and advertised, and the disparity between the sale price and the $6.5 million assessed value continue to plague the council.
In meetings in May, June and July, citizens concerned about the sale of the building at Washington and Park streets stepped forward to ask questions — most of which went unanswered.
The purpose of the workshop was to determine how to address the growing chorus of criticism of the sale of the property, which was largely accomplished out of the public eye.
Mari Eosco was absent. Here are some of the comments from other council members:
Carolyn Lockwood: “I take executive session very seriously. I don’t feel I need to answer any additional questions.”
Andy Winglass: “I believe that the City Council made the right decision and we got a good price. I will not answer.”
Steve Brackett (asked by Wyman if he would answer questions): “No.”
Meadow Rue Merrill: “My goal was to help my neighbors, but, no, I won’t answer additional questions about the sale.”
Sean Paulus: “Did I learn anything by this? Yes. But I trust our city staff and the opinions of my fellow councilors. I will not add anything to that.”
Tink Mitchell: “I’m looking forward to the draft (of new rules) by the economic development committee. Beyond that, I have nothing to say.”
David Sinclair: “I don’t believe we did anything wrong, and I see no problem in answering these questions. But I bow to the will of the council.”
Privately, Sinclair met with Bath residents Larry Scott and Michael Wischkaemper while seeking counsel from the city solicitor, Roger Therriault.
Therriault cited the state statutes governing Freedom of Access exemptions in public proceedings, specifically §405. C, which prohibits “discussion or consideration of the condition, acquisition or the use of real or personal property permanently attached to real property or interests therein or disposition of publicly held property or economic development only if premature disclosures of the information would prejudice the competitive or bargaining position of the body or agency.”
The statute was put in place to protect cities and towns from competition in purchasing or selling real estate where a competitive process exists. An example might be a situation in which a city is bidding against another buyer for a piece of land to build a school. If the bidding limit is known, the city would be at a competitive disadvantage.
However, in the sale to Smith, there was no competition in place, because no one knew the building was for sale.
The building, though listed with an agent, was never placed on the Multiple Listing Services notices. City Manager
William Giroux has said the building was deliberately held out of the MLS listings until City Council was given a chance to review the deal.
The asking price was also an issue that many citizens brought up at the past three meetings.
City Assessor Paul Mateosian said the assessed value of tax-exempt properties is an irrelevant number, since no tax is assessed on the value.
He noted that the value listed in the database for the property is a “cost-approach number,” based on what it would cost to build a hospital that size, minus depreciation, and is not intended to reflect what the sale value would be.
He said that the value was needed for insurance purposes. He also said that when revaluations are done, taxexempt properties are never reassessed.
However, former City Council member Kyle Rogers, himself a real estate broker, said the assessed value has other uses.
“Those are the figures we use when we’re asked to demonstrate enough collateral to issue bonds, for instance,” he said. “There are other purposes to the assessment, even though the city isn’t realizing a dime of property tax from exempt properties.”
He questioned the low sale price.
At Wednesday’s meeting, Wischkaemper and Scott spoke out in favor of a more transparent process. They were joined by Adair Delamater of West Milan Street, who lives not far from the hospital building.
“I am concerned about the appearance of potential wrongdoing,” Delamater said. “I came to encourage development of a policy that says sales should be held in a public hearing, and published in the newspaper 30 days before the sale.”
John James of Garden Street acknowledged that the council “may have learned a few valuable lessons on process.”
He said the hospital building was a maintenance nightmare and that getting $799,000 for it was “a blessing.”
“It’s time to move on past this,” he said. “We have a lot of serious problems in the city. Our waterfront needs work. Our business park needs some economic development. This building is sold, and we got a good price for it.”
Ed Rogers, owner of J.R. Maxwell’s, said he believed criticism of the council was unfair.
“They’re doing the best they can,” he said. “Bath has turned around in the last 20 years, and it’s because Bath citizens have worked together. There has been no scandal here.”
Some of the councilors also acknowledged lessons learned; many said they support the city’s economic development committee researching a change to the city charter that would make real estate sales more transparent and involve the public more in the process.
The committee met Tuesday to begin the work of drafting a new system. Wischkaemper and Scott are participating in that process.
The proposed new rules will come before the council on Aug. 7 for review.
TO WATCH VIDEO OF THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING, CLICK HERE.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less