3 min read

Katherine Chatterjee
Katherine Chatterjee
On Monday, June 24, The Times Record published yet another of Edward A. Tharp’s ramblings as a guest columnist (“LePage is the last chance for Maine’s working class,” Page A6).

First, I would question: What justifies the continuing publication of such diatribes which take up so much editorial space and which make misleading, false and slanderous accusations against everyone who disagrees with Governor Paul LePage’s behavior and policies?

Secondly, I would like to offer some selected and limited comments regarding statements made in that guest column: “limited” because it serves no useful purpose to try to refute so many untruths.

If one analyzes each paragraph of what was published, no paragraph makes any sense, is false, is slanderous or is intentionally dishonest. There are no references that can be checked and no proof of anything asserted.

As an example, comments regarding death panels made by Sarah Palin are stated as fact, yet they have been proven false and are not part of the health care reform legislation. Other false and intentionally misleading statements regarding health care reform, its costs and quality, are also made with nothing to corroborate those assertions.

Advertisement

There are many more specific comments that could be made; however, the point I wish to make is that readers should beware of what is being published as “guest columns.” It is one thing for a newspaper to offer differing opinions, but what Mr. Tharp writes is — in my opinion — absurd, nonsensical, extremely partisan and in many instances patently false.

His sentences and paragraphs have no meaning except to confuse the public. I feel certain there are many knowledgeable people in our reading area that could provide more insight and understanding to today’s complex problems.

Monday’s Times Record had another very brief but interesting news item: “State 13th in study of children’s health.” That article is factually relevant to the discussion of Maine, its budget, where it has been and where it is going. It is very relevant to the viewpoints held by Mr. Tharp, Gov. LePage and their budget-cutting extremism.

Let’s ask ourselves, how did Maine become “No. 1 in health status and No. 6 in family and community,” as indicated by the study?

This was not happenstance and no credit for those high rankings goes to Gov. LePage. These rankings are the result of the past 50 years of Maine people who care about the welfare of others working together to provide greater access to quality health care at an affordable cost. Many state and federal government agencies, legislators, nonprofit organizations, health care providers and facilities have cooperated in increasing access to appropriate health care in a timely fashion for Maine’s uninsured and under-insured population.

This has been an intentional, hard-fought struggle which has yielded results. With the cuts to MaineCare proposed by Gov. LePage, and his veto of the continuation and expansion of services to 70,000 more people, Maine will not be in this enviable position in a few years once the effects of his curtailments are felt.

Advertisement

This same study indicated Maine is “ranked in the 20th spot in both education and economic well-being.” Let’s ask ourselves another question: What will Maine’s ranking be five years from now if Gov. LePage’s cuts to our educational and health care systems are allowed to be implemented?

There always has been and always will be a direct correlation between educational achievement, health care and economic well-being.

These facts have been proven many times by many experts and studies.

Mr. Tharp’s ramblings and disinformation and Gov. Le- Page’s rantings and threats will not change the facts. Maine’s No. 1 ranking in health status and No. 6 in family and community will certainly soon deteriorate, and Maine’s No. 20 ranking in education and economic wellbeing will plummet.

It is the responsibility of each and every one of us to see that every person has access to quality health care, a good education, food and shelter for themselves and their families.

Then, and only then, will their economic well-being be ensured.

Advertisement

Then, and only then, will Maine raise its economic wellbeing ranking.

KATHERINE CHATTERJEE is a former Harpswell selectwoman who spent 45 years in the health care profession.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.