4 min read

Gina Hamilton
Gina Hamilton
The real question Mainers should be asking themselves is, “Why is this even a political issue?”

As every Mainer who is awake (and a pathetically large number of Mainers — and other Americans — out of state) has learned over the last couple of weeks, government in Maine has become a rather sad case of tit for tat.

Not that this should be a surprise, when one considers what is going on in Washington on any given day. But somehow, Maine has always seemed immune to the playground antics that characterizes other states’ governments and the federal government as well, so it is pretty disappointing.

But on an issue that will 1) provide health care coverage for most low-income people in Maine, including many childless young adults who are no longer eligible for parents’ insurance, and 2) save the state hundreds of millions of dollars, while 3) paying off all the hospital bills that have accumulated over the last 20 years and 4) assuring that such a debt never accumulates again, it seems like politics shouldn’t even be part of the equation.

Maine is in a unique situation, because we as a state chose to expand Medicaid coverage to many additional people years ago. Of its own free will, Maine expanded coverage under the Baldacci administration. Gov. Paul LePage proposed scaling it back, but it was a difficult sell, politically, especially in a state where the average income is low and insurance costs are relatively high. Medicaid, or MaineCare, is a popular program.

Advertisement

LePage was banking on the Supreme Court to render the Affordable Care Act (also known as Obamacare) unconstitutional. However, a year ago, it upheld all of it except for the requirement for states to expand Medicaid.

However, that didn’t apply to Maine, because Maine had already expanded Medicaid, and deep within the ACA was something called the “continuation of effort” provision that prevented Maine from rescinding the MaineCare expansions it had already had in place before the ACA was voted on in Congress.

So Maine is required to continue almost all of its MaineCare program.

There was an effort to get the government to allow Maine to rescind its expansion, and a little argument about expediting the request, which the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services refused to do last fall; and an effort to force them to expedite their decision failed in the First Circuit Court. The goal, apparently, was to try to get the Medicaid expansion rescinded before the November elections, LePage assuming (correctly) that he would no longer have a majority, nor an attorney general who would do his bidding, after that.

However, when the nonexpedited decision came, in October, Maine was prevented from rescinding its expansion in any case. Some childless disabled adults (who were covered under Medicare for the majority of their care) were exempted, but LePage didn’t have the votes to end their supplementary care in any case.

Maine’s generous support of parents was scaled back slightly, ending MaineCare for parents who earned between 133 and 150 percent of the poverty line.

Advertisement

So everyone assumed at the time that LePage would see that it was logical to accept federal dollars for something he wasn’t going to be able to stop in any case.

MaineCare expansion won’t cost Maine a nickel. In fact, it should save the state somewhere between $65 million and $118 million over six years, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.

So the recent kerfuffle in the Legislature was something of a surprise.

Almost all Republicans, asked (on video) separately, supported expanding MaineCare and accepting federal dollars. It’s absurd not to do so, since MaineCare is popular among Mainers and will save the state a lot of money.

The vote in the committee was encouraging, too.

But when the Democrats tied hospital repayment to MaineCare expansion and acceptance of federal dollars, Republicans stood together in opposition.

Advertisement

When the bill passed anyway, given that Democrats have the majority, LePage vetoed the bill, presumably because it was not a solution that he, Himself, had sponsored.

Republicans, even those who had stated clearly and unequivocally that they supported MaineCare expansion and the acceptance of federal dollars to support it, doggedly voted to uphold the veto.

The upshot is, hospitals aren’t getting their money, the poor aren’t getting needed health care, and the state isn’t getting more than $100 million that is badly needed.

What is wrong with this picture?

GINA HAMILTON, of Bath, is editor of the New Maine Times. She welcomes emails at editor@newmainetimes.org.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.