
So I was interested to learn, 11 years later, that Kleiman is leading the team hired to advise Washington state as it designs something the modern world has never seen: a fully legal commercial market in cannabis. Washington is one of the first two states (Colorado is the other) to legalize the production, sale and consumption of marijuana as a recreational drug for consumers 21 and older. The marijuana debate has entered a new stage. Today the most interesting and important question is no longer whether marijuana will be legalized — but how.
“At some point you have to say, a law that people don’t obey is a bad law,” Kleiman said. He has not come to believe marijuana is harmless, but he suspects that the best hope of minimizing its harm may be a well-regulated market.
Ah, but what does that look like? A few places, like the Netherlands, have had limited legalization; many jurisdictions have decriminalized personal use; Maine and 17 other states have approved the drug for medical use.
But Washington and Colorado have set out to invent a whole industry from scratch.
The biggest shadow hanging over this project is the Justice Department. Federal law still makes felons of anyone who trades in cannabis, and no one expects Congress to remove cannabis from the list of criminal substances any time soon.
Attorney General Eric Holder, perhaps preoccupied with scandal management, has been slow to come up with enforcement guidelines.
One challenge facing the legalization pioneers is how to keep the marijuana market from being swallowed by a few big profiteers — the pot equivalent of Big Tobacco, or even the actual tobacco industry — a powerful oligopoly with every incentive to turn us into a nation of stoners.
What Kleiman and his colleagues imagine as the likely best model is something resembling the wine industry — a fragmented market, many producers, none dominant. This could be done by limiting the size of licensed purveyors.
It would help, too, to let individuals grow a few plants at home — something Colorado’s new law permits but Washington’s does not.
If you read the proposal Kleiman’s team submitted to Washington state, among the things on the to-do list are certifying labs to test for potency and contamination; devising rules on labeling, so users know what they’re getting; hiring inspectors, to make sure the sellers comply; establishing limits on advertising (you don’t want “allowing” to become “promoting”).
All these rules must account not just for smoking but for pot pastries, pot candies, pot-infused beverages, pot lozenges, pot ice cream, pot vapor inhalers.
One of the selling points of legalization is that states can take a cut of what will be, according to estimates, a $35 billion to $45 billion industry. It’s the same tactic used to win public approval of lotteries — and with the same danger: Some worthy government function comes to depend on creating more addicts.
And how do you divvy up the revenues? How much goes to offset health consequences? How much goes to enforcement? How do you calibrate taxes so the price of pot is high enough to discourage excessive use, but not so high that a cheap black market arises? All this regulating is almost enough to take the fun out of drugs.
And then there is the issue of drugged driving. Much about the chemistry of marijuana in human beings remains uncertain, so no one has come up with a pot version of the breathalyzer to determine quickly whether a driver is impaired. In the absence of solid research, some legalization advocates insist stoned drivers are more cautious, and thus safer. (Hands up if you want Harold and Kumar piloting your airplane.)
On this and much else, Washington and Colorado will probably be making it up as they go, waiting for science to catch up.
California’s medical marijuana law is such a free-for-all that in Los Angeles there are now said to be more pot dispensaries than Starbucks outlets.
Even advocates of full legalization say things have gotten out of hand.
“It’s a bit of a farce when you can watch people come out of a dispensary, go around the corner and resell their drugs,” said Gavin Newsom, the lieutenant governor and former San Francisco mayor, who favors legalization. “If we can’t get our medical marijuana house in order, how do we expect voters to deal with legalization?”
BILL KELLER writes for the New York Times News Service.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less