3 min read

A Sagadahoc County Superior Court judge made no ruling Tuesday on a motion to dismiss West Bath’s lawsuit against Regional School Unit 1 and three of its member communities.

Justice Andrew Horton said West Bath’s case is “weak” but also said this is a case of “significant public interest.”

West Bath claims $1.9 million in damages due to inequities in a former RSU 1 cost-sharing formula.

The town filed its complaint under Rule 80B of the Maine Rules of Civil Procedure, which governs the ability to change government action. Such a filing must be made within 30 days.

West Bath did not bring its case until last year.

Advertisement

“There is an appropriate way for the town to proceed,” Horton said. “I’m confident a motion to dismiss could stand, but the town could take new action based on extraordinary circumstances.”

Sally Daggett, the attorney representing

West Bath, had told the court her client could cite “extraordinary circumstances.”

Jonathan Davis, town administrator for West Bath, said after the hearing an amended filing based on extraordinary circumstances could be in the works.

“That would be our intent right now,” Davis said. “The Board of Selectmen could discuss that with legal counsel in an executive session.”

Neither Davis nor Daggett would specify what might constitute extraordinary circumstances.

Advertisement

Daggett said it wasn’t until spring 2012 that West Bath officials knew of the inequities in the funding formula, based at the time one-third on each town’s pupil count, one third on population and one-third on property valuation.

She also said that Bath city officials “might have known of the problem” earlier. Daggett also pointed out that both RSU 1 school board members who represent West Bath also represent Bath.

After Tuesday’s hearing, one of the attorneys representing Bath, David Ray, said any allegations against Bath city officials were not part of the original complaint.

“This isn’t the claim (Daggett) was making until today, making some kind of accusation of nefarious conduct,” Ray said.

Horton said West Bath could have appealed the costallocation plan as early as 2008. But West Bath officials contend they had no knowledge that the formula was unfair.

“There is nothing on that assessment warrant that says ‘we are changing the costsharing formula,’” Daggett said. “West Bath thought the formula agreed upon was correct. We never thought the LD 910 requirements were not being adhered to.”

Advertisement

LD 910 was the special legislation through which RSU 1 was created in 2007. The legislation included the one-third, one-third, one-third allocation.

Some communities argued in 2012 that the formula was applied only to the district’s costs that exceed the Essential Programs and Services model. The remainder was figured according to the state’s EPS funding plan, and that decision was based on an oral legal opinion — not a written one — when the district was created.

The board changed its formula in 2012 so that all costs were allocated through the “one-third” formula, and has since changed its allocation to one based on cost per pupil.

Horton said earlier he was “going to operate on the assumption that everyone was mistaken. West Bath shouldn’t be the only one on notice.”

David Kallin, representing RSU 1, emphasized that there is no way RSU 1 could find the money to repay West Bath.

“Once the legislative body has voted to raise those taxes and the fiscal year has passed,” Kallin said, “West Bath has no relation to that money.

“Once the taxes have been collected, there’s no way to get that money back. There is no legal means for a municipality to recover it.”

lgrard@timesrecord.com



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.