
Religious considerations aside, the rationale for not permitting gay unions up til now has been that same-sex marriages do not produce offspring.
While it is true that two women or two men cannot produce a child, the same can be said about many heterosexual couples with marginal or no fertility. These couples resort to other options for completing their families, including in vitro fertilization, sperm donation, surrogacy or adoption.
And many married couples decide in the end that their family is complete without children, especially older married couples.
So the idea that a same-sex union would not have the same options for having children or not seems, on its face, to be a silly argument. If couples were tested for fertility before being granted a marriage license, many would not be allowed to marry, regardless of their gender.
Of course, we wouldn’t dream of preventing our parents from remarrying in their old age, or keeping our sisters and brothers who are infertile from having a meaningful relationship within the bonds of matrimony.
Indeed, from an economic perspective, it is beneficial to society to have as many married couples as possible, whether they are adding to the surplus population or not.
Married couples with two similar incomes, filing jointly, still pay a higher percentage of their income as income tax than single people do, even if they are cohabitating. For a couple with no children, this “marriage penalty” can be thousands of dollars.
Married couples with children get to exempt them, if they don’t itemize their deductions, and they have the additional benefit when their tax dollars go to finance schools and preschools and college supports — which the married couple with no children will never see.
Married couples without children and two comparable incomes are less likely to be eligible for tax credits, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit.
Married couples without children and two comparable incomes tend to have more disposable income in general, which is plowed into the local economy, supporting small businesses that may well consist of parents with children.
A wedding is usually the most expensive party in a person’s life. Invitations, gowns, attire, flowers, restaurants, bands, deejays, cakes, favors, trips and gifts are all part of a typical ceremony. All of this is money spent at some local venue — except in the case of “destination weddings,” of which Maine has a fair share — and little of it can be outsourced. That means small businesses benefit from any wedding, and increasing the number of weddings is good for them. Allowing same-sex weddings would have a stimulative effect on small businesses that cater to weddings.
Newly married couples who set up housekeeping are also stimulative to the economy. Many purchase new homes or — at least — furnishings and appliances for a rental.
They buy insurance, often for the first time in their lives.
They start saving for their eventual retirement. They may invest. They may buy a pet or two, an industry that leads to millions of dollars of spending on pet supplies.
Even couples who have been married for many years make purchases together that neither would be able to afford separately — new cars rather than used, a cottage for weekend getaways, a boat, an anniversary piece of jewelry or trip.
Any marriage equality would mean that couples would be entitled to federal benefits of marriage, including a small survivor’s benefit for Social Security, VA, military or federal employee pension survivor benefits, any marriage benefits such as being able to visit a spouse in the hospital or jail, and more.
This is only basic fairness and should be extended to other “couples” that have lifelong commitments, even if unmarried. An example would be two sisters who live with one another their whole lives, or a child who lives with a widowed parent. However, that’s not on the docket this year.
Overall, the benefits to samesex unions far outweigh any drawbacks, from an economic perspective.
And establishing a baseline for fairness, regardless of sexual orientation, will benefit us all in the end, and the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered children who may grow up knowing nothing but equality as they face their own issues of sexual orientation.
GINA HAMILTON, of Bath, is editor of the New Maine Times. She welcomes emails at editor@newmainetimes.org.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less