Bowdoin College likely will get permission to renovate a former assisted-living facility on Harpswell Road into its newest student dorm.
Whether that happens by zoning ordinance change or grant of a special permit remains to be determined.
Two months ago, the college announced its intent to buy the former Stevens Home building — which had been a 16-bed elder-care facility until 2011 — and renovate it into a dormitory that could house up to 35 students.
To do that, the town first had to change the zoning ordinance in the area to make residence halls a permitted use. Currently, the MU3, or mixeduse, zone allows for privately owned boarding houses but not institutionally owned dormitories.
Planning Board members recommended approval of the zone change last week but declined to include a specialpermit option in its considerations.
A special permit is more restrictive than a permitted use, and to include it Planning Board deliberations now would mean having to start the public hearing and consideration process all over again — which Planning Board Chairman Charlie Frizzle said last week it would not do.
So town councilors Monday agreed to widen the town’s options by including the possibility of granting the college a special permit to renovate the building for a dorm — without changing the zone.
They set an April 1 public hearing on the issue.
Standards for awarding a special permit are tougher and more subjective than a zone-permitted use.
If Planning Board members review the project and determine it could have possible adverse impacts on neighbors, they could deny a special permit outright.
But with a permitted use, as long as a proposed project meets zoning guidelines, it cannot be denied, even if it potentially may have some negative effects on neighboring property owners. The Planning Board can impose some conditions to mitigate the potential effects, but cannot reject a project that meets its regulations.
District 7 Councilor Sarah Brayman offered the amendment to include the special permit in the town council’s consideration.
District 2 Councilor Ben Tucker seconded Brayman’s amendment “not necessarily because I’m committed to it, but … because if we hear from people (during the public hearing) next week that they think it should be a special use, then we’re only going to lose time.”
The amendment passed by a 7-2 vote, with District 1 Councilor David Watson and District 5 Councilor Gerald Favreau opposed.
A subsequent vote to approve the amended motion and set the hearing date passed by the same count, but with Favreau and council Chairwoman Suzan Wilson in opposition.
Bowdoin has maintained that the revamped residence hall’s footprint would not change, and that it would be a chem-free “quiet” dorm.
But some who live in the tiny MU3 district remain unconvinced of Bowdoin’s claims. Harpswell Place resident Reed Bartlett is concerned about the precedent that could be set if zoning is changed.
“The issue for us is the number of properties the college owns in the neigborhood,” Bartlett said. “If the zoning is changed, the college could (potentially) be permitted to build residence halls on three sides of our property — which essentially puts us in the middle of a college campus.”
He added that he is looking forward to hearing about the effects a special permit would have on the project, compared to that of a permitted use.
“Right now, we don’t know what the options are, what the restrictions would be,” Bartlett said. “It’s extremely difficult to speak out against the wishes of Bowdoin College. People really do care about college encroachment into the neighborhood, but they’re worried and they don’t want to be a pariah in a community that is rightfully grateful for the college’s contributions.”
jtleonard@timesrecord.com
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less