4 min read

Ben Tucker
Ben Tucker
It would be irresponsible for us to remain silent while corporate tax breaks could be handed out in Augusta at the expense of Brunswick taxpayers.

Governor LePage’s justannounced budget would cost Brunswick over $3 million in cuts to our schools and town services, and cause an increase in property taxes. At the same time, the governor’s administration, with the support of some legislators, is proposing to exempt one company from paying any property taxes at all.

This is not a recipe for successful economic development; it is a recipe for economic disaster.

Long before Kestrel Air located at Brunswick Landing, the Midcoast Regional Redevelopment Authority was notified that Kestrel’s activities would be subject to property taxation. The town has a responsibility to treat all businesses and property owners equally when it comes to tax exemptions, and it carefully applies that law in making tax assessments.

John Richardson
John Richardson
When the town was advised of the nature of Kestrel’s planned business, we looked at the law and consulted our attorneys, the Maine Municipal Association and others. We were advised that, given the nature of the work that Kestrel would be undertaking at Brunswick Landing, it did not meet the law’s requirements for a tax exemption.

Advertisement

Today, Kestrel’s use of the property still fails to qualify for an exemption.

The company is using the property as a laboratory to design, test materials for, and construct molds for aircraft to be built in Wisconsin.

These uses do not qualify for an exemption under Maine law because they do not provide a public use or general support for the airport. In the future, should Kestrel’s use of the property change, it may qualify for some level of exemption.

With this in mind, it puzzles us as to why, only now, MRRA and the governor feel a “clarification” of the law is necessary. Neither party has shared with us the proposed legislation, which leads us to believe that it is not, in fact, a “clarification” but rather an expansion of the law to provide a special-interest tax exemption for Kestrel.

Even stranger: Kestrel has never asked the town for an exemption.

More puzzling still is the suggestion that Brunswick is the only town taxing such activities, thereby putting Brunswick Landing at a competitive disadvantage.

Advertisement

In fact, we are aware of other communities that levy a property tax for aeronautical uses at municipal airports.

Today at Brunswick Executive Airport, there are thriving businesses that do qualify for the tax exemption. Neither the fixed-base operator nor the flight training school pays any real estate taxes.

The closing of the base has been described by the State Planning Office as the equivalent of the closing of five paper mills in one community.

That community is Brunswick and Topsham.

We have repeatedly been told that this is a regional impact. We do not disagree, but the epicenter is here. Brunswick lost the lion’s share of military dependents, which has resulted in the loss of millions of dollars for our schools. Topsham has been hit hard with the closure of facilities there.

The bottom line is that the town of Brunswick has suffered as a result of the loss of the base. Brunswick, not Kestrel needs a break.

Advertisement

We look forward to working with the legislative delegation to focus on restoring funding rather than further reducing town revenue.

It is crucial we get beyond this dispute and establish a mutually beneficial relationship. In order for this to occur, we should take a look back at the success of the initial Local Redevelopment Authority and the Community Relations Board. That model worked for a variety of reasons, including direct participation and involvement by the town, plus greater transparency and public participation.

There would be greater confidence in MRRA if there were more of both.

The town is ready, willing and able to work with the MRRA board to assist redevelopment. In fact, during 2011-12, when the town was negotiating a possible Tax Increment Financing district with MRRA, it considered a TIF and tax rebate covering Kestrel’s activities as part of an overall TIF package. However, that package was derailed when the governor’s office mysteriously proposed legislation to dictate that the town turn over 80 percent of taxes from the overall TIF district to MRRA.

With that history, the introduction of further legislation to dictate tax breaks is counterproductive. The only way to get back on track is to allow the town and the MRRA Board to build a relationship without threats from Augusta.

The state needs to let the local communities decide what priorities are important in their communities. Specifically, legislators need to concentrate on matters that are the domain of the state, not the local towns. We need them to be there when we need help from the state, but we don’t need them to meddle into the prerogatives of the towns or the day-to-day interactions between the town and the MRRA. Some in our delegation have been better at this than others.

Advertisement

In the final analysis, successful redevelopment depends on the working relationship between MRRA and the towns of Brunswick and Topsham.

We hope Brunswick councilors, Topsham selectmen and MRRA board members will soon start meeting to build relationships with the host communities. So let’s get started.

JOHN RICHARDSON is a practicing attorney and former Speaker of the Maine House, House Majority Leader and commissioner of the Department of Economic and Community Development. BEN TUCKER is a practicing attorney who grew up in Brunswick and attended Brunswick schools. Both serve on the Brunswick Town Council.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.